By Kevin Hardy, Stateline.org
Outrage erupted final month when Oklahoma Metropolis residents discovered of plans to transform a vacant warehouse into an immigration processing facility.
Making issues worse was the secrecy of the federal authorities: Metropolis leaders acquired no communication from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement apart from a mandated disclosure associated to historic preservation.
Planning a significant growth with out metropolis enter is antithetical to the in-depth, generally arcane allowing, planning and zoning course of in Oklahoma Metropolis. Mayor David Holt, a former Republican state senator, stated these land use choices are among the many most important of any municipal authorities.
“For any entity to have the ability to open a detention heart in our communities, doubtlessly subsequent to neighborhoods or colleges, no matter your views on immigration coverage or enforcement, may be very difficult, as a result of that’s a really high-impact use, and that’s the form of factor that we might anticipate to speak about,” he advised Stateline.
Communities throughout the nation are going through related prospects as ICE undertakes a large growth fueled largely by the file $45 billion accredited for elevated immigration detention by Congress final summer season.
Throughout President Donald Trump’s second time period, ICE is holding a file variety of detainees — greater than 70,000 as of January — throughout its personal amenities in addition to in contracted native jails and personal prisons. ICE paperwork from final week present plans for buying and renovating 16 processing websites that maintain as much as 1,500 folks every and eight detention facilities that maintain as much as 10,000 every, for a complete capability of 92,600 beds. The company additionally has plans for some 150 new leases and workplace expansions throughout the nation, Wired reported.
However ICE’s plans to transform industrial buildings — typically warehouses — into new detention amenities have just lately confronted fierce opposition over humanitarian and financial considerations. From Utah to Texas to Georgia, native governments have sought to dam these large amenities. However with restricted authorized authority, metropolis and state officers have turned to the court docket of public opinion to discourage personal builders and the federal authorities.
Holt, who’s the president of the U.S. Convention of Mayors, a nonpartisan group representing the greater than 1,400 leaders of cities with populations of 30,000 or extra, stated cities have little authorized recourse over the ICE amenities.
“All of us have a transparent, unified place that actually crosses occasion traces,” he stated, “after which we even have a transparent understanding of how restricted our choices are.”
Native leaders typically cite the U.S. Structure’s supremacy clause, which says federal legal guidelines supersede conflicting state legal guidelines. That leaves cities with restricted affect over initiatives that would take industrial area off tax rolls, trigger new strains on metropolis providers and lift critical humanitarian considerations given the Trump administration’s aggressive immigration enforcement, together with the high-profile killings of two Individuals in Minnesota.
Going through bipartisan opposition, the out-of-state proprietor of the Oklahoma Metropolis warehouse in the end determined to finish talks of promoting or leasing its warehouse to the federal authorities.
Comparable public stress has proved efficient in reversing plans in a number of different cities: In late January, a Canadian agency stated it will not proceed with a deliberate sale of a Virginia warehouse after it confronted requires a boycott from Canadian politicians and companies. In Mississippi, U.S. Sen. Roger Wicker introduced the federal authorities would“look elsewhere” after he spoke with Division of Homeland Safety Secretary Kristi Noem, who oversees ICE. Wicker, a Republican who stated he helps immigration enforcement, echoed native financial considerations of a challenge deliberate in Byhalia.
Some officers have welcomed the brand new amenities: Missouri Republican U.S. Rep. Mark Alford has lobbied to land a detention and processing heart in his district. And final week, a Maryland county accredited a decision expressing its “full assist” for ICE, which is contemplating buying a warehouse there, regardless of native protests. However most communities have fought them.
Neither DHS nor ICE responded to Stateline’s questions.
Holt stated the dialogue resembles different native growth considerations the place NIMBY — quick for Not in My Yard — is a standard description of opponents.
“There are many people who find themselves very law-and-order and supporters of legislation enforcement who don’t need a jail subsequent to their home,” he stated. “That’s why it’s acquired such broad opposition: NIMBYism is probably the most highly effective power generally in American politics and no one needs a detention heart subsequent to their house, their enterprise or their faculty.”
A political and authorized struggle
After studying that ICE deliberate to take over a vacant warehouse inside its metropolis limits, the Kansas Metropolis Council in January swiftly accredited a five-year ban on nonmunicipal detention amenities.
Kansas Metropolis Council member Andrea Bough, who can be a non-public growth legal professional, stated the transfer was each political and authorized: The town wished to ship a transparent sign opposing ICE amenities, however it additionally needs to exert its native authority over planning and zoning.
She acknowledged the authorized hurdle posed by the supremacy clause, however stated there was sufficient ambiguity over the town’s skill to control land use that it could take the difficulty to the courts.
“Some would say native constructing codes and zoning laws don’t apply to the federal authorities,” she stated. “That’s one thing I feel we might most likely on this scenario be keen to struggle till we had clear steering on that.”
Following weeks of stress, the Kansas Metropolis agency that owns the 920,000-square-foot warehouse introduced Thursday it was not “actively engaged with the U.S. Authorities or some other potential purchaser,” the Kansas Metropolis Star reported.
Jackson County, which incorporates parts of Kansas Metropolis and the potential detention facility, is contemplating an identical ban. And throughout the state line, the Unified Authorities of Wyandotte County and Kansas Metropolis, Kansas, is contemplating an identical two-year moratorium.
However there are clear limitations on cities’ skill to cease federal initiatives, stated Nestor Davidson, a professor who teaches land use and native authorities legislation at Harvard College’s Graduate Faculty of Design.
“The federal authorities can assert immunity from sure state and native legal guidelines, together with zoning, however it’s sophisticated, and there are nuances,” he stated.
Nonetheless, Davidson stated some case legislation has proven cities might have stronger authorized footing for zoning guidelines which might be broad and never immediately focused at particular federal authorities initiatives.
“I anticipate to see litigation,” he stated. “I feel you’re going to see these conversations play out as land use fights typically do: each in a authorized venue and in a political venue.”
Governments pressured to behave
Kansas Metropolis’s moratorium has sparked curiosity amongst native activists who’ve pressured elected officers in different cities throughout the nation to behave. However many native officers are adamant that federal legislation ties their arms.
In a authorized opinion supplied to the Orlando Metropolis Council in Florida, Metropolis Lawyer Mayanne Downs rejected “recommendations of actions we are able to supposedly take,” together with moratoriums or utilizing zoning ordinances to dam ICE detention facilities.
“Nonetheless nicely motivated these recommendations are, the legislation may be very clear: ICE, as an company of our federal authorities, ICE is immune from any native regulation that interferes in any manner with its federal mandate,” Downs wrote to the mayor and metropolis commissioners.
ICE is reportedly contemplating a brand new $100 million processing heart in southeast Orlando.
The county fee in Orange County, which incorporates Orlando, mentioned the difficulty final week after receiving related authorized recommendation. County Commissioner Nicole Wilson stated the board is much more constrained due to a latest Florida legislation limiting sure native governments’ skill to control growth by means of 2027.
After being suggested towards passing a moratorium, the board agreed with Wilson’s follow-up suggestion to draft a decision expressing its opposition. That might be thought of at a future assembly.
“It doesn’t sound prefer it has the enamel {that a} moratorium would have, however it basically provides an consciousness that we’ve established a place in opposition to this kind of facility in Orange County,” Wilson advised Stateline.
An legal professional by commerce, Wilson stated the case legislation relating to federal initiatives largely facilities on disputes about publish places of work, which she stated shouldn’t be an applicable comparability to the large detention facilities at the moment contemplated.
“A publish workplace has the identical water consumption and sewage as most likely plenty of different makes use of,” she stated. “For those who take a warehouse that was designed for 25,000 widgets and put 15,000 people in it, you’ve acquired a really totally different set of native wants and providers which might be getting used and being taxed and being burdened.”
Working with the feds
Communities have typically opposed numerous different federal initiatives, similar to federal courthouses. However the federal authorities typically takes the time to hearken to native considerations and talk constructing plans with communities, stated Jason Klumb, a former regional administrator with the U.S. Normal Companies Administration, which manages the federal authorities’s actual property.
“Typically, GSA has had form of a great neighbor strategy, understanding that they’ve necessities for federal amenities, and a few of these amenities might not all the time be well-liked,” stated Klumb, an Obama appointee.
However the federal authorities has not been shy about exerting its constitutional authority.
For instance, late final month, GSA introduced it will construct a brand new $239 million federal courthouse in downtown Chattanooga, Tennessee, regardless of bipartisan lobbying from metropolis and federal officers for a special web site.
“The feds get what the feds need, in the end,” Klumb stated.
In a press release, a GSA spokesperson declined to make clear the company’s present position in buying ICE detention amenities. The assertion stated the company was “following all lease procurement procedures in accordance with all relevant legal guidelines and laws.”
Communities have largely been ignored of the administration’s immigration decision-making course of.
“Many of the info we’ve got acquired on this facility has been by means of information leaks and the federal government has not reached out to us but,” stated Paul Micali, the city supervisor of Merrimack, New Hampshire.
By way of an open data request, the ACLU of New Hampshire confirmed that ICE was planning to transform a 43-acre warehouse property within the city of about 28,200.
The federal plans had been obtained from the state’s historic preservation workplace, which got here underneath hearth for not informing Republican Gov. Kelly Ayotte of ICE’s proposal. That company’s prime official resigned final week after stress from Ayotte.
Ayotte’s workplace didn’t reply to a request for remark. On Thursday, her workplace launched paperwork detailing how the federal authorities’s$158 million plan to retrofit the property would create tons of of long-term jobs for the area.
Testifying earlier than Congress Thursday, an ICE official stated the feds won’t cancel the challenge over native considerations.
Micali stated the vacant warehouse at the moment offers about $529,000 in annual property taxes — a considerable sum given the city’s property tax base of about $20 million.
In a letter to Noem, the City Council stated changing the property to a tax-free federal facility would lead to greater native taxes for residents. Merrimack can be involved about potential calls for for water, hearth and different metropolis providers, Micali stated, however can’t even start to evaluate wants with out extra particulars from the feds.
He’s talking with legal professionals about what choices, if any, the city might have to claim native zoning energy.
“We’re taking a look at each risk,” he stated.
Stateline reporter Kevin Hardy will be reached at khardy@stateline.org.
©2026 States Newsroom. Go to at stateline.org. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
