England legend Chris Waddle questions Arsenal’s pursuit of Sandro Tonali, highlighting the Newcastle midfielder’s striking similarities to Declan Rice.
Waddle’s Analysis on Midfield Overlap
Tonali delivers a standout season at St James’ Park, positioning him as one of the Premier League’s top central midfield targets ahead of the summer window. Arsenal showed strong interest in January after Mikel Merino’s injury, exploring a deal for the 25-year-old. Newcastle firmly rejected any mid-season sale of their key asset, leaving the Gunners empty-handed.
Manchester United now competes in the race, seeking elite midfield additions. Newcastle sets a £100 million valuation on Tonali, with head coach Eddie Howe emphasizing the Italian’s vital role in team plans.
Waddle expresses surprise at Arsenal’s interest, given their midfield depth including Rice and Martin Zubimendi. “They’ve got Declan Rice and they’ve got Martin Zubimendi, who’s a very good player,” Waddle states. “Tonali has had a couple of great seasons, he’s got better this season. He’s a good age and I’m not surprised there’s a lot of clubs interested in him.”
He describes Tonali as economical, consistent in passing, with a strong shot and high work rate—much like Rice. “In my mind, he’s a very similar player to Declan Rice. Do Arsenal really need another player like that?” Waddle adds. “I know squads strengthen every year and that’s how football moves on.”
Newcastle’s High Demands
Waddle advises Newcastle to hold firm unless offers exceed £80 million. “If Alexander Isak went for £120m, they’ve got to be looking at his age, the quality and the consistency he’s shown. You’ve got to be looking around £80-100 million,” he notes.
Tonali’s Impact and Contract
Tonali features in 104 appearances across three years at Newcastle, contributing to their historic Carabao Cup triumph last season. A 10-month betting ban limited his debut year to eight league games. His contract extends to June 2028, with a one-year extension option.
Shearer’s Warning on Retention
Club legend Alan Shearer warns Newcastle risks losing Tonali without Champions League qualification. “Top players want to play Champions League football, and we know there’s no real loyalty in football,” Shearer observes. “If Newcastle aren’t going to qualify for Europe or be competitive in the Premier League, you’d expect other clubs will look at Newcastle and try to buy their best players.”
Newcastle must boost Premier League form and cup runs to retain stars like Tonali amid rising expectations.
