An Orange County, California, highschool scholar mentioned he was suspended after his “Make America Nice Once more” hat was stolen, sparking a political argument with one other scholar.
Laguna Seaside Excessive Faculty scholar Zach Hornstein informed Fox Information Digital that he and several other mates wore MAGA hats on Sept. 11 to honor Charlie Kirk, the Turning Level USA co-founder who was shot and killed throughout a talking occasion at a Utah school campus the day earlier than.
“His dying actually affected us,” Hornstein mentioned. “I could not agree with all the things he says, however I respect that he encourages college students to suppose critically, take into account either side, and have interaction in sincere discussions. My mother is an immigrant, and I used to be introduced as much as love America. On Sept. 11, I wished to really feel patriotic and present my assist for our nation as a complete.”
On the finish of the college day, Hornstein mentioned, a feminine scholar grabbed his hat and threw it within the ladies’ lavatory trash can. A political argument adopted, throughout which the scholar used profanity when talking about President Donald Trump, based on KTTV-TV, Fox 11 Los Angeles.
Hornstein mentioned the group “received over it and moved on” however, at a instructor’s course, he filed an incident report and requested a written apology. The varsity later suspended each college students.
Hornstein referred to as the suspension “extraordinarily upsetting” as a result of it interfered along with his rigorous AP class schedule.
“To today, I don’t perceive what I used to be truly suspended for,” he informed Fox Information Digital. “Through the argument, I jokingly mentioned, ‘Should you don’t like America, Canada has open borders,’ which was confirmed by quite a few college students, together with the woman who took my hat off.”
Hornstein mentioned he and the opposite scholar stay mates, and he believes college directors made a mistake.
“She was suspended as nicely, and I imagine that it was a whole overreaction,” he mentioned. “I feel it was a extremely emotional day for everybody on 9/11, and he or she made a mistake for which she later apologized.”
“We had been capable of work by way of it in a wholesome manner, and I want the adults concerned had modeled that very same strategy as a substitute of making extra division,” he added.
His mom, Janet Semenova, informed Fox Information Digital her son is an honor roll scholar and had by no means been disciplined earlier than.
She believes her son was focused due to his political opinions.
“I feel it’s a double customary,” she informed Fox11. “I feel youngsters who’ve sure political opinions are held to a distinct customary than youngsters who produce other political opinions.”
The Laguna Seaside Unified Faculty District mentioned it doesn’t self-discipline college students for expressing political beliefs and issued the next assertion:
“We’re legally required to maintain scholar self-discipline issues confidential to guard the privateness and well-being of all college students. Defending free expression is prime to our democracy, and faculties play a essential position in serving to younger folks navigate differing viewpoints with respect. Our duty as educators is to assist college students in participating by way of constructive dialogue and wholesome debate that’s respectful, empathetic, and rooted in civil discourse. Highschool is a formative time, and we’re dedicated to serving to college students develop into considerate residents who perceive each their rights and obligations in a various neighborhood,” a spokesperson for the district informed Fox Information Digital.
“When disputes come up on campus, faculties should consider the habits concerned. California legislation defines the grounds for suspension, and we’re reviewing the information on this state of affairs by way of that course of to make sure it’s dealt with pretty and constantly,” the assertion continued.
The district’s gown code doesn’t prohibit college students from sporting political attire, and Hornstein mentioned college students are allowed to put on clothes with political messages so long as it’s applicable.
Semenova mentioned the household plans to enchantment the suspension earlier than the college board.
“We deeply love this college and its lecturers, which makes our disappointment within the administration’s dealing with of this delicate state of affairs much more pronounced,” she informed Fox Information Digital. “What we actually need is an acknowledgment from the college that they might have accomplished higher and used this as a chance for studying and development, as a substitute of a second that created additional division.
“It’s troublesome to be an adolescent, and I imagine that it’s our ethical duty to assist them turn out to be extra empathetic and tolerant adults. On this, maybe we are able to all study a lesson from the late Charlie Kirk.”
