An immigration decide has blocked the Trump administration from deporting Mohsen Mahdawi, a Palestinian graduate scholar who led protests at Columbia College in opposition to Israel and the conflict in Gaza.
In a ruling made public by Mahdawi’s attorneys on Tuesday, the decide, Nina Froes, stated she had terminated the case due to a procedural misstep by authorities attorneys, who did not correctly certify an official doc they meant to make use of as proof.
The Trump administration might enchantment the choice. However the ruling marked the newest setback for the federal authorities’s sweeping effort to expel pro-Palestinian campus activists and others who expressed criticism of Israel.
Mahdawi, a authorized everlasting resident of the U.S. for the final decade, was arrested by immigration brokers final April throughout what he thought was a citizenship interview. He was launched two weeks later after an order from a federal decide.
Within the months since, the federal government has continued its effort to deport him, citing a memo from Secretary of State Marco Rubio arguing noncitizens might be expelled from the nation if their presence might undermine U.S. international coverage pursuits.
Authorities attorneys submitted a photocopy of the doc to the immigration decide, however they did not certify it as required beneath federal legislation, the decide wrote.
“I’m grateful to the courtroom for honoring the rule of legislation and holding the road in opposition to the federal government’s makes an attempt to trample on due course of,” Mahdawi stated in a press release launched by his attorneys. “This determination is a crucial step in direction of upholding what concern tried to destroy: the correct to talk for peace and justice.”
Mahdawi has additionally mounted a separate case in federal district courtroom arguing that he was unlawfully detained. That case stays ongoing, his attorneys stated.
Tricia McLaughlin, a spokesperson for the Division of Homeland Safety who’s leaving her publish subsequent week, forged Mahdawi as a frontrunner of “pro-terrorist riots” whose visa must be revoked in a press release to The Related Press.
“No activist decide, not this one or every other, goes to cease us from doing that,” she added.
The Trump administration has arrested and sought to deport a number of worldwide college students who participated in pro-Palestinian campus protests, accusing them of antisemitism and citing a federal legislation that lets the secretary of state block visas for individuals who may pose “adversarial international coverage penalties for the US.” The scholars have sued the federal government over their detention, arguing they’re being punished for First Modification-protected speech.
The federal government has accused Mahdawi of “threatening rhetoric and intimidation of pro-Israeli bystanders” throughout protests on Columbia’s campus, which he has denied.
One other Columbia activist and inexperienced card-holder, Mahmoud Khalil, was arrested in March 2025 and is at the moment combating a bid to deport him. An immigration decide ordered him to be deported in September, which he’s interesting. On a separate monitor, a U.S. district courtroom decide freed him from immigration detention final summer season, a ruling that was overturned by a panel of appellate judges final month, although Khalil is anticipated to problem that transfer.
And final month, a separate immigration decide blocked the federal government’s try and deport a Tufts College graduate scholar, Rümeysa Öztürk, over an op-ed criticizing the varsity’s response to the conflict in Gaza.
