The Kitchen Sisters manufacturing workforce takes a glance into the lengthy held Scottish custom of honesty bins – the place you permit the cash within the field and take what you want.
SCOTT DETROW, HOST:
Honesty bins are an extended and wealthy Scottish custom. You will discover them alongside rural roads, on the finish of driveways, subsequent to farmhouses or out in the course of nowhere. Generally they could be a rickety picket cupboard stocked with home made jam. Different occasions, an deserted phone filled with cabbages or leaks or kale or possibly hen.
What all of them have is a worth record and the implicit understanding that if you need a shortbread or a dozen eggs or the rest, you’ll go away cash within the honesty field. Nobody is there to observe you. It is a belief factor. Right now, the Kitchen Sisters, Davia Nelson and Nikki Silva, take us on a tour of the honesty bins of Scotland.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: An honesty field is sort of a little magical factor that sits beside the highway in rural Scotland. They’re fairly childlike. You type of anticipate to see animals or one thing in them or easter eggs. And in them, they’re stuffed to purchase, and you permit cash. There’s no person going to verify you. Was once eggs, principally – then it simply grew and grew. You get shortbread, traybakes, Scottish pill – you recognize, that tremendous candy, teeth-destroying, scrumptious factor – plenty of knitted issues, a great deal of apples. Something that may be grown within the West of Scotland, you are going to get it unlocked within the honesty field.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Laughter).
ANNIE: You’ve got bought home made apple chutney, a tray of shortbread for six kilos, Gigha (ph) home made pill – a neighborhood, conventional Scottish candy – faculty cake. Yeah. My son’s nodding. He is 5 years previous, and he will get a few of that at college. And a lemon drizzle – every good has a worth. Simply put some cash within the tin ‘trigger it is an honesty field. So I put in 20 kilos, and I take my change of 10 kilos. There’s fairly some huge cash in there, so I am assuming that others are doing the identical.
My title is Annie, and I am right here visiting Gigha with my household. We’re from Northumberland within the northeast of England. And there is numerous honesty bins there, truly. While you’re in someplace so rural as this in Scotland, there is a respect for the area people, to make use of the honesty field because the locals would need. There’s lots of people that need to stay with these form of morals of belief.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
NICKY BROWN: I used to be nearly to go and get the eggs from the hens to place within the field.
Right here, ladies. Who has laid this morning?
The older ladies – you possibly can see they simply molted. That is why they have not bought many feathers on a few of them. I am Nicky Brown. My husband, Pete, has simply left the island to take a bull to market. We’re at Clachaig Farm on the Isle of Arran.
We do not have a lot to place within the field simply now as a result of we have solely simply planted the greens, leeks, kale, all of the brassicas, and beetroot, peas, beans, pumpkins, courgettes.
My elder son’s in-laws got here to remain and stated, you have bought so many cabbages. Why do not you promote some? I went, oh, no, nobody’s going to need to purchase our greens. And that is the place it began. Only a wee field on the finish there. It is an previous plastic ice cream prime. And other people simply put their cash in there and take change if they should.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
BROWN: I’m positive issues would possibly go lacking. Effectively, so what if it is the odd cabbage? I strongly consider that 99% of individuals are trustworthy. If you happen to belief individuals, then they’re trustworthy with you, principally.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
MARK COUSINS: Very seldom are individuals dishonest. I might assume very seldom, I might guess. We will not be too romantic or sentimental about this. You understand, in a metropolis like Glasgow, the most important metropolis in Scotland, there’s plenty of poverty, plenty of poverty, plenty of social deprivation (ph) You could possibly not go away a field of cash sitting there as a result of individuals are going to take it ‘trigger they want cash to feed their youngsters or to feed their drug habits or no matter.
My title’s Mark Cousins. I am a filmmaker. I dwell right here in Edinburgh. While you go to the Western Isles the place you noticed these honesty bins, there is a much less excessive distinction between wealthy and poor and which means that only a few individuals are so determined for 5 kilos that they will take it out of your field. So I feel that is one of many sensible the reason why the cash is not nicked on a regular basis.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #3: Honesty field – you depend on individuals’s honesty. You come to Gigha, you place your 15 kilos within the wee picket field, you signal within the guide to say, my title’s John, and I’ve paid 15 kilos, after which go and play your golf and play as a lot or as little golf as you need, from first gentle to final gentle.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #4: John Bannatyne.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #3: He is up within the wheelhouse. He is on the wheelhouse.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #4: He is the person that appears after the golf course – he cuts the grass, dyes the greens, tidies all of it up. On his spare time, on his week off from the boat, that is what he does.
JOHN BANNATYNE: I am John Bannatyne. I am the secretary of Isle of Gigha Golf Membership. I am additionally the skipper of the ferry that goes from the Kintyre Peninsula. Once I’m not driving the ferry and I’ve to get a while off, I volunteer on the wee nine-hole golf course on Gigha. We simply keep it up the custom of volunteering in order that the individuals of Gigha have the chance to play golf.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
JAMES: While you come to a spot like this in Scotland, there isn’t any clubhouse as such. As you possibly can see, it is a shed, actually a backyard shed. They do not have the funds to employees a clubhouse. And a great deal of them have honesty bins, and it depends on individuals simply placing their money in. And all people respects it, and it really works.
Out right here enjoying golf, appropriately – I am James. I am right here on the island of Gigha.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
SCOTT ELAND: Ah.
I am Scott Eland from Portland, Oregon. My purpose is to play each golf course in Scotland, and I do not assume it is ever going to occur. We began on the farthest north that you can go. It was a one-way highway for about an hour and a half, and no person was up there. No staffing, nothing, simply – it was nearly like a previous bus cease. We put 5 kilos in a mailbox, and it is an honor deal, and you then go stroll 9 holes, and also you’re accomplished.
In Eire, we went to the farthest north golf course in Eire, and it was the very same factor, the honour golf. Every household on the town that performs golf is assigned a sure gap to mow and care for. And you can inform as a result of some holes have been higher than different ones. Some individuals had a knack.
CHARLES COLIN MACLEOD CURRIE: My title is Charles Colin Macleod Currie. My household have been on this space at Blackwaterfoot for over 300 years. My grandfather equipped eggs. He additionally had a milk run down right here. He had a very battered previous land rover. The doorways did not match. And once I was a wee boy, we’d load up with milk and drive to the golf course first after which come alongside right here and ship milk to every of the homes.
Farming was a really exhausting life. The honesty field would come about in the event you get surplus product and you may’t arrange a store. Individuals would consider stealing as completely towards the lifestyle. And also you’re in a local people, so if stuff was being stolen, finally, any person would discover out who was doing it, and you’ll be fully reduce adrift.
CATHERINE ANNE MACPHEE: My youthful sister, Holly (ph), simply opened up her first field, so it is brilliant pink. It is on the finish of my mother and father’ drive, and it says Holly’s field. She’s bought a QR code on the door, and there’ll simply be a tin there to place the cash in. She’s promoting it on Fb. She’s additionally created its personal Instagram web page, as many others do, so you possibly can carry on prime each, like, what’s in that week. She’s been making muffins, jams, sticky toffee pudding, millionaire shortbreads – at all times fashionable by Scottish.
My title’s Catherine Anne MacPhee (ph). I’m an archivist and activist within the Isle of Skye. Honesty bins appear to have boomed within the final 10 years in locations like Skye and different islands within the Hebrides. You see them in every single place. Effectively, it is very nice to see one on the finish of the household house.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #5: Some individuals would possibly assume that honesty bins are from the previous, from a special age, an easier age, a extra trustworthy age. However I might say they are a future factor, as nicely. Because the web and COVID, much more individuals are capable of dwell in rural communities, and these honesty bins are little embroidered edges to their lives.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #6: People are trustworthy. Most people are trustworthy. The truth that you are providing them one thing and trusting their honesty makes them much more trustworthy. I feel it is vital. Society will break down in the event you can not belief the individuals that you simply’re in it with.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
DETROW: “The Honesty Containers Of Scotland” was produced by the Kitchen Sisters with Mark Buell and George Bull. It was combined by Jim McKee. You’ll be able to hear extra Kitchen Sister tales on their podcast, “The Kitchen Sisters Current.”
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts might differ. Transcript textual content could also be revised to appropriate errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative document of NPR’s programming is the audio document.
