Greater than a decade in the past, California outlawed using canine to chase black bears. The apply, often known as hounding, was condemned for its cruelty and unfair benefit for hunters. Now, Meeting Invoice 1038 seeks to carry it again, permitting hounds to pursue bears throughout a newly proposed “pursuit season.” Supporters declare the measure would assist curb rising conflicts between folks and bears, whereas critics warn it might devastate wildlife and worsen the issue.
Assemblymember Heather Hadwick, who represents rural communities within the state’s northeast, argues that California’s bear inhabitants has grown “uncontrolled” and poses a risk to human security. She factors to the state’s first recorded deadly black bear assault in 2023 as justification for reintroducing hounds into bear administration, the Mercury Information studies.
Hounding bears was banned in California in 2012.
Battle or Coexistence
California’s solely bear species is the black bear, which thrives throughout the Sierra Nevada, coastal ranges, and foothills. Whereas their inhabitants was as soon as estimated at round 35,000, up to date strategies recommend nearer to 65,000 — although specialists warning that these figures are imprecise.
Wildlife strategist Wendy Keefover notes that apex predators reproduce slowly and stay at low densities, making sweeping claims about explosive inhabitants development unreliable, he advised the Los Angeles Instances.
The spike in human-bear encounters, significantly in Lake Tahoe and Southern California’s foothills, stems not from extra bears however from extra folks transferring into and vacationing inside bear habitat. Between 2017 and 2020, the state logged a median of 674 bear-related studies yearly. That determine greater than doubled to 1,678 throughout 2021 and 2022. Bears have realized to make the most of straightforward meals sources — trash cans, chook feeders, out of doors pet meals, and even unlatched automobile doorways.
A brand new invoice seeks to carry again hounding by means of a “pursuit season.”
Why Hounding Doesn’t Work
Proponents of AB 1038 body hounding as a type of hazing meant to revive bears’ worry of people. However animal welfare advocates counter that chasing random bears deep within the forest has nothing to do with the precise conflicts unfolding close to properties and campsites.
Ann Bryant, government director of the Tahoe-based Bear League, advised SFGATE that unleashing hounds is not going to educate bears to keep away from folks. As an alternative, it dangers driving them nearer to human settlements.
The cruelty is one other central difficulty. Bears typically run for miles till cornered or compelled up bushes. Exhaustion, damage, or violent clashes with packs of canine may end up. In previous seasons earlier than the ban, bears chased into bushes turned straightforward targets for hunters ready beneath. As ABC7 Information studies, critics warn the brand new invoice blurs the road between non-lethal hazing and a return to full-scale searching.
Black bears are the one bear species left in California.
The Higher Options
Consultants insist that coexistence instruments are far simpler than reintroducing hounds. Securing rubbish, putting in electrical fencing round livestock enclosures, and eradicating meals temptations from yards and campsites forestall most conflicts. Movement-activated lights, alarms, and even “unwelcome mats” that ship a gentle shock deter curious bears with out cruelty.
Bryant stresses that actual hazing ought to be speedy and situational — stomping ft, shouting, or scaring a bear away from trash in the mean time it misbehaves. Pursuing them by means of wilderness with canine, she explains, isn’t hazing in any respect. It’s harassment.
Grizzly bears had been hunted to extinction within the state a century in the past.
What’s at Stake
California as soon as misplaced its grizzly bear to overhunting, leaving solely its picture on the state flag. Now the black bear, an adaptable and clever survivor, faces a brand new push that might destabilize populations and erode hard-won protections. Whereas residents understandably worry harmful encounters, hounding is unlikely to make communities safer. Because the Los Angeles Instances studies, the hot button is to not terrorize bears however to show folks learn how to responsibly stay in bear nation.
If AB 1038 advances, the state dangers repeating errors of the previous. Bears would as soon as once more be chased for sport below the guise of administration, whereas the actual options — training, prevention, and coexistence — are pushed apart.
Click on beneath to make a distinction.
