Reporting Highlights
- Rightward Shift: Lengthy earlier than the Trump administration started pushing patriotic curricula and increasing personal faculty alternative, Oklahoma experimented with a lot of these conservative concepts.
- Classroom Management: State legislation restricts how lecturers deal with classes about racism and gender — and the supplies they maintain of their school rooms.
- Pockets of Resistance: Some educators and fogeys have balked on the conservative motion in colleges, with authorized challenges slowing a lot of mandates.
These highlights had been written by the reporters and editors who labored on this story.
The future that the Trump administration envisions for public colleges is extra patriotic, extra Christian and fewer “woke.” Wish to understand how which may play out? Look to Oklahoma.
Oklahoma has spent the previous few years reshaping public colleges to combine classes about Jesus and encourage delight about America’s historical past, with political leaders and legislators working their means by way of the conservative agenda for overhauling training.
Lecturers, educators and critics alike confer with Oklahoma as floor zero for pushing training to the proper. Or, as one trainer put it, “the canary on the prairie.”
By the point the second Trump administration started espousing its “America First” agenda, which incorporates the growth of personal faculty vouchers and prohibitions on classes about race and intercourse, Oklahoma had been there, carried out that.
The Republican supermajority within the state Legislature — the place some members determine as Christian nationalists — handed sweeping restrictions on instructing about racism and gender in 2021, prompting districts to evaluate whether or not lecturers’ classes may make college students “really feel discomfort, guilt, anguish” or different psychological misery about their race. The next 12 months, it adopted one of many nation’s first anti-transgender faculty toilet payments, requiring college students to make use of restrooms and locker rooms according to the gender they had been assigned at delivery or face self-discipline.
Whereas he was state colleges superintendent, Ryan Walters demanded Bibles be positioned in each classroom, created a state Workplace of Non secular Liberty and Patriotism, and inspired colleges to make use of on-line “pro-America” content material from conservative media nonprofit PragerU. He referred to as lecturers unions “terrorist” organizations, railed in opposition to “woke” school rooms, threatened to yank the accreditation of college districts that resisted his orders and commissioned a take a look at to measure whether or not trainer candidates from liberal states had “America First” data.
Most of the modifications endorsed by the state’s leaders have parts of Christian nationalism, which holds that the USA was based as a Christian nation and sometimes downplays troubling episodes within the nation’s historical past to as a substitute emphasize patriotism and a God-given future.
Walters, who declined to remark for this story, resigned on the finish of September and have become CEO of the Instructor Freedom Alliance, an arm of the conservative suppose tank Freedom Basis that goals to “battle the woke liberal union mob.” However a lot of the transformation in Oklahoma training coverage that he helped turbocharge is codified within the state’s guidelines and legal guidelines.
“We’re the testing floor. Each single state wants to concentrate,” warned Jena Nelson, a reasonable Democrat who misplaced the state superintendent’s race to Walters in 2022 and is now working for Congress.
ProPublica has reported that Schooling Secretary Linda McMahon has introduced in a workforce of strategists who’re working to radically shift how kids will be taught in America, whilst they perform the “last mission” to close down the federal company. A few of these strategists have spoken of their want to dismantle public training. Others hope to push it in the identical path as Oklahoma.
Walters tapped the president of The Heritage Basis, a conservative suppose tank that printed Undertaking 2025 and the blueprints that preceded it, to assist rewrite Oklahoma’s social research requirements. The Legislature didn’t reject the rewrite, so the requirements now embrace roughly 40 factors concerning the Bible, Jesus and Christianity that college students ought to be taught in addition to skepticism concerning the 2020 presidential election outcomes and the origins of COVID-19. If the brand new requirements survive a authorized problem, they could possibly be in place till they’re up for evaluate once more in six years.
However whereas Oklahoma made these shifts, it has persistently ranked close to the underside on nationwide measures of scholar efficiency. Scores on eighth grade studying and math in nationwide evaluations are abysmal. Solely New Mexico’s proficiency charges rank decrease. The highschool dropout price is without doubt one of the highest within the nation, whereas spending on training is without doubt one of the lowest. Solely three different states — Utah, Idaho and Arizona — spend much less per pupil. And in the latest federal knowledge about common trainer pay, Oklahoma tied with Mississippi for lifeless final. Many faculty superintendents and fogeys say state leaders have been fixated on the unsuitable issues if the objective is to enhance colleges.
“The eye to the tradition conflict factor implies that there’s numerous distraction from the essential wants of youngsters being met,” stated Aysha Prather, a mother or father who has intently adopted modifications in state training coverage. Her transgender son is a plaintiff in a 2022 lawsuit difficult the state’s toilet ban. That case stays on enchantment.
“The varsity must be the nicest, happiest, greatest resourced place in a group,” she added. “That’s how we present that we worth youngsters. And that’s clearly not how most of our Legislature or state authorities feels about it.”
In an announcement to ProPublica, the brand new state superintendent, Lindel Fields, stated that he’s sorting by way of earlier guidelines and edicts which have created “a lot confusion” for colleges, together with concerning the requirements and the PragerU trainer certification exams. He stated the general public rightfully has questions on how the state Schooling Division modifications after Walters’ tenure, however “given all these urgent duties, we merely don’t have time for wanting backward. Whether or not we’re fiftieth or forty sixth or twenty fifth in training, we’ve work to do to maneuver our state ahead,” Fields wrote. He stated his first duties are “resolving a lot of excellent points which might be hindering operations” together with making a funds for the company.
Public faculty superintendents don’t oppose all the mandates from the previous a number of years. When Walters directed colleges final 12 months to put Bibles in each classroom and train from them, one district superintendent emailed to thank him for providing “cowl” to include Bible-focused classes, in line with information studies.
One other superintendent, Tommy Turner of Battiest Public Faculties, stated college students at his colleges have all the time had entry to the Bible. The district nonetheless places on a Christmas program and observes a second of silence to start out the day, and the college board prays earlier than conferences.
“Christ by no means left the college,” he stated in an interview in his workplace.
A lifelong Republican who works in a distant stretch of southeast Oklahoma, Turner stated he’s involved concerning the state’s priorities and doesn’t see Bibles as essentially the most urgent points.
In his district, the cafeteria wants repairs even after the emergency alternative of a roof that had a gaping gap in it. A lot of his lecturers work second jobs on weekends as a result of the pay’s so low. Nail heads are poking by way of the fitness center’s skinny hardwood flooring. The district has misplaced 15% of its college students to an internet constitution faculty and homeschooling. Voters have rejected three bond points in a row for constructing repairs and renovations.
Turner stated he’d prefer to retire, however he loves the scholars and desires to guard his little district. He placed on his cowboy hat, apologized for the pile of lifeless wasps on his workplace flooring — the infestations barely register anymore — and walked over to the highschool. He stated he hadn’t even learn the brand new social research requirements.
“I don’t have time to chase each rabbit,” he stated. “I’ve obtained a college to run.”
Credit score:
Nick Oxford for ProPublica
Patriotism and Jesus
The modifications to Oklahoma’s curriculum guidelines don’t simply contact on nationwide points round race and gender. Right here, lecturers aren’t supposed to inform college students that the Tulsa Race Bloodbath of 1921 — a defining incident of racial violence in Oklahoma historical past — was perpetrated by racists.
State social research requirements for years have included dialogue of how white Tulsans murdered as many as 300 Black folks. However as soon as the 2021 state legislation that restricted instructing about race and gender handed, some lecturers prevented the subject.
The legislation prohibits lecturers from singling out particular racial teams as liable for previous racism. It specifies that people of a sure race shouldn’t be portrayed as inherently racist, “whether or not consciously or unconsciously.” Along with lecturers’ licensure being on the road, repeated failure to conform would permit the state to revoke district accreditation, which may lead to a state takeover.
When educators questioned find out how to train a few race bloodbath with out working afoul of the legislation, state legislators and the Tulsa County chapter of the conservative mother or father group Mothers for Liberty weighed in to say that white folks right now shouldn’t really feel disgrace and that the bloodbath’s perpetrators shouldn’t be solid as racists. A Mothers for Liberty chapter consultant didn’t reply to questions from ProPublica.
At a talking engagement on the Norman Public Library in 2023, Walters urged lecturers current the information concerning the murders however mustn’t say “the pores and skin coloration decided it.” Even two years after the legislation went into impact, information studies stated lecturers had been nonetheless treading frivolously on the race bloodbath, cautious of the state suspending or revoking their licenses for exposing college students to prohibited ideas. These fears usually are not hypothetical; the state has revoked at the very least one trainer’s license and suspended two others’.
Different historic episodes that reveal racism are also getting a brand new look in Oklahoma by way of the state’s partnership with PragerU Children, which creates short-form movies to counter what its founder believes is left-wing ideology in colleges.
Academics within the state aren’t required to make use of the movies, however some like them and present them in school. The movies align with conservatives’ push to show a constructive view of America’s previous and with the state’s guidelines on instructing about race and gender. As an illustration, PragerU Children’ model of Booker T. Washington’s story is a cheery lesson in self-sufficiency and acceptance. As soon as free of slavery, Washington toiled in coal mines, labored as a janitor in change for formal training and have become an incredible American orator and chief of the Tuskegee Institute in Alabama.
The video doesn’t linger on his being born into “essentially the most depressing, desolate and discouraging environment” or, as he wrote in his autobiography, that slavery was “a sin that at a while we will should pay for.”
“America was one of many first locations on Earth to outlaw slavery,” a cartoon model of Washington tells two time-traveling kids within the PragerU video, so “I’m proud and grateful.” (The U.S. did ban importing slaves in 1808, nevertheless it didn’t implement that legislation and didn’t outlaw proudly owning folks altogether till 1865, after Britain, Denmark, France and Spain had carried out so.)
The Washington character says within the video that he devoted his life to instructing folks “the significance of independence and making themselves as beneficial as attainable.” And when one little one says she’s sorry that he and different Black People confronted segregation and discrimination, Washington thanks her for her sympathy however assures the kid, who’s white, that she’s carried out nothing unsuitable.
Echoing a conservative speaking level, the cartoon Washington says, “Future generations are by no means liable for the sins of the previous.”
Jermaine Thibodeaux, a historian on the College of Oklahoma, stated he’s acquainted with the PragerU movies and considers them an ideological software of a “reeducation venture nationwide” that may be deceptive.
“I don’t suppose that’s one thing Washington essentially uttered,” he stated of the quote about future generations.
The worth Washington positioned on independence, Thibodeaux added, was “predicated on the notions of self-sufficiency post-slavery, when there was little assist coming from the federal government.”
A spokesperson for PragerU declined to remark for this story.
Credit score:
PragerU
Strain to maintain squeezing social justice and LGBTQ+ points out of school rooms has been intensifying since 2021, when Republican state lawmakers started pushing “soiled ebook” laws that may censor faculty libraries. One invoice, which didn’t cross, referred to as for firing faculty workers and fining offenders $10,000 every time they “promoted positions in opposition to intently held non secular beliefs of the scholar.” That was the backdrop when the state accused Summer season Boismier of “ethical turpitude” after which revoked her instructing license final 12 months.
The English division at Norman Excessive Faculty close to Oklahoma Metropolis instructed Boismier and her colleagues they wanted to drag titles that may be thought of racially divisive or comprise themes about intercourse and gender. Or they might flip books round on the cabinets so college students couldn’t see the titles.
“I keep in mind simply sitting in my seat shaking. I had colleagues within the room who had been in tears,” Boismier stated. Given the selection to purge books or cover their covers, Boismier did neither. She wrapped her classroom’s bookshelf in crimson butcher paper and wrote “books the state doesn’t need you to learn” on it in black marker. She added a QR code linking to the Brooklyn Public Library, the place college students may get a library card and digital entry to books thought of inappropriate in Oklahoma, then posted a photograph of all of it on social media.
Boismier, who resigned in protest of the 2021 legislation, challenged the license revocation in court docket, and the case is ongoing. She stated she doesn’t remorse taking a stand in opposition to a legislation she views as unjust. The state has argued the revocation is legitimate.
“I’m dwelling each trainer in Oklahoma’s worst nightmare proper now,” she stated. “I’m unemployable.”
Credit score:
Nick Oxford for ProPublica
Within the Battiest district, the place Turner is superintendent, an elementary studying trainer instructed ProPublica that simply to be secure, she eliminated books about range and together with others who’re completely different. She stated that was uncomfortable; half of her college students are Native American, and so is she.
Adopted this 12 months, the state’s new social research requirements present much more specifics about what must be taught. They embrace the expectation that college students know “tales from Christianity that influenced the American Founders and tradition, together with the teachings of Jesus of Nazareth (e.g., the ‘Golden Rule,’ the Sermon on the Mount),” to second graders. A state court docket final month issued a brief keep on requiring colleges to comply with the requirements whereas a lawsuit in opposition to them performs out.
As well as, the brand new requirements settle for Trump’s false claims concerning the 2020 election. They dictate that ninth graders find out about “discrepancies” in election outcomes together with “the sudden halting of ballot-counting in choose cities in key battleground states, the safety dangers of mail-in balloting, sudden batch dumps, an unexpected file variety of voters” and different unsupported conservative speaking factors. The Trump marketing campaign and supporters filed at the very least 60 lawsuits overlaying these factors; almost all had been dismissed as meritless or had been determined in opposition to Trump. The election skepticism normal has left the superintendent of a roughly 2,000-student district north of Tulsa confused. He stated he and different superintendents are uncertain how they’d navigate these however are hopeful that “requirements rooted in reality prevail.”
“There comes a degree the place curriculum can’t be opinion,” stated the superintendent, who didn’t need to be named as a result of he feared retaliation. “I’m not making an attempt to get entangled in conspiracy theories.”
Credit score:
Nick Oxford for ProPublica
Concern and Resistance
The push by state leaders to embed extra Christian values in colleges isn’t what retains many superintendents within the rural elements of the state up at evening. They are saying the Bible has by no means left their school rooms.
“I’m smack-dab proper in the course of the Bible Belt,” stated the chief of a tiny district on the western facet of the state. “We’re small, however we’ve seven church buildings. You’re speaking ‘Footloose’ right here.”
Whereas she doesn’t disagree with every little thing the Legislature and Walters have carried out, she stated she seems like a few of their actions undermine public colleges and will “shut down rural Oklahoma.”
She and different leaders of public faculty districts fear that the state’s expanded faculty alternative program, which permits households to get tax credit in the event that they attend personal and non secular colleges, will draw away college students from their districts and, finally, erode their funding. Congress handed the primary federal personal faculty tax credit score in July.
It’s simply the second 12 months of the statewide tax credit score program permitted by the Legislature that enables college students to make use of public funds to attend personal and non secular colleges. The credit value the state almost $250 million in tax income this faculty 12 months and subsidizes nearly 40,000 college students. That cash, superintendents say, is desperately wanted of their districts.
The state additionally has inspired the expansion of constitution colleges, that are publicly funded however privately run and topic to fewer rules. Final 12 months, the state’s third-largest district, behind the Oklahoma Metropolis and Tulsa districts, wasn’t a conventional one. It was EPIC, a statewide on-line constitution faculty. Walters and Gov. Kevin Stitt supported St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Digital Faculty in its efforts to change into the nation’s first non secular constitution faculty. The Supreme Court docket blocked it from opening.
Even communities with few personal colleges really feel threatened by the state’s push towards privatization. At Nashoba Public Faculty, in a rural a part of southeast Oklahoma the place there’s little else however timber and twisting roads, the roughly 50 youngsters who make up the elementary and center grades are taught in split-grade school rooms. Like a whole bunch of different Oklahoma districts, greater than three-quarters of that are rural, it’s not only a faculty, it’s the college; there aren’t any personal colleges in Pushmataha County.
When college students enroll in constitution colleges, they usually take funding with them whereas districts have to take care of operations as earlier than.
“You starve your public colleges to feed your personal colleges and constitution colleges,” stated Nashoba Superintendent Charles Caughern Jr. “Our basis was arrange for a free and acceptable training for all youngsters. All youngsters!”
Credit score:
Nick Oxford for ProPublica
Caughern fears college students with disabilities will undergo as public colleges are weakened. Non-public colleges don’t should admit college students with disabilities, and lots of gained’t, he stated.
Erika Wright, a mother or father who leads the Oklahoma Rural Faculties Coalition, which advocates for public colleges, stated the state’s deep-red politics may lead outsiders to suppose Oklahomans assist state leaders pushing training far to the proper. However that’s not the case, Wright stated.
“They don’t perceive what’s taking place,” Wright stated. “They only assume that public colleges are all the time going to be there as a result of they’ve all the time been there of their lifetime. I feel the common Oklahoman doesn’t perceive the gravity and complexity of what’s going down.”
That’s to not say there isn’t resistance. A gaggle of about 15 dad and mom and public faculty advocates that Walters derided because the “woke peanut gallery” goes to State Board of Schooling conferences — a visible reminder that individuals care about training coverage and public colleges. A suburban Oklahoma Metropolis district is devising plans to ship all the Bible classes contained within the new social research requirements on the identical day, giving dad and mom a simple approach to have their kids decide out. Court docket challenges to a few of the state’s right-wing insurance policies are pending.
Some are hopeful that Oklahoma will recalibrate the extra excessive insurance policies that marked Walters’ tenure. The State Board of Schooling final week determined to not revoke the licenses of two lecturers who Walters needed punished for his or her social media posts about Trump. The brand new superintendent stated he would drop Walters’ plan to distribute Bibles to each classroom.
However lots of the important modifications in school rooms got here out of the Legislature, which has continued this 12 months to suggest payments to rid colleges of “inappropriate supplies” and proclaim that, in Oklahoma, “Christ is King.” Loads of injury already has been carried out to public colleges, stated Turner, the Battiest superintendent.
He was solely half-joking when he stated some dad and mom have been “brainwashed” by right-wing TV information and Oklahoma leaders’ speak of liberal indoctrination to suppose the district is instructing youngsters to be homosexual or changing Christian youngsters into atheists.
A few years in the past, one mother stopped him within the parking zone at college to say she was withdrawing her little one from the district as a result of its instructing didn’t align along with her values. The superintendent was floored.
“That’s the ability of the rhetoric,” Turner stated.
He stated he used to take a seat a few pews behind that mother in church each Sunday.
Megan O’Matz and Asia Fields contributed reporting.
