To remain updated on our newest investigations, be part of Bellingcat’s new WhatsApp channel right here.
This investigation is a part of a collaboration between Bellingcat and Evident. You may watch Evident’s video right here.
Youngsters in Chicago’s Outdated Irving Park neighbourhood have been getting ready for a Halloween parade on Oct. 25 when federal brokers reportedly deployed tear gasoline on the road to disperse protesters opposing immigration-related arrests within the neighbourhood.
“These children have been tear gassed on their option to have fun Halloween of their native faculty parking zone,” US District Choose Sara Ellis stated in court docket on Tuesday, in line with a CBS Information report. “I can solely think about how terrified they have been”.
Ellis was questioning US Customs and Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino over this and different incidents that protesters allege violate a momentary restraining order (TRO) she issued earlier this month.
The Oct. 9 TRO was issued after a gaggle of journalists, religion leaders and protesters filed a lawsuit in opposition to the Trump administration over what they described as a “sample of maximum brutality” by federal brokers in opposition to peaceable protesters since Operation Halfway Blitz – a multi-agency operation in opposition to “legal unlawful aliens” in Illinois – started on Sept. 2.
Subscribe to the Bellingcat e-newsletter
Subscribe to our e-newsletter for first entry to our printed content material and occasions that our employees and contributors are concerned with, together with interviews and coaching workshops.
When Choose Ellis requested Bovino to provide all use-of-force stories since Sept. 2 from brokers concerned in Operation Halfway Blitz by the top of Tuesday, Bovino stated it could be unimaginable due to the “sheer quantity”. Ellis then ordered Bovino to show over these stories, together with the accompanying physique digicam footage, by the top of Friday, Oct. 31.
The court docket order locations restrictions on federal brokers’ crowd-control measures throughout the state, together with their use of “riot management weapons” equivalent to tear gasoline and pepper spray, the usage of pressure in opposition to people and requiring folks to go away public areas that they lawfully have the proper to be in.
A subsequent court docket submitting on Oct. 27 alleges that federal brokers have violated the TRO “nearly day by day” because it was issued. “Immigration enforcement doesn’t sometimes require the day by day use of tear gasoline on civilians in residential areas,” the submitting acknowledged.
Bellingcat’s evaluation of social media movies from 28 occasions in Illinois from Oct. 9 to Oct. 27 discovered a number of examples of pressure and riot management weapons getting used.
In complete, we discovered seven that appeared to indicate the usage of riot management weapons when there was seemingly no obvious fast risk by protesters and no audible warnings given. Nineteen confirmed use of pressure, equivalent to tackling folks to the bottom once they weren’t visibly resisting. One other seven confirmed brokers ordering or threatening folks to go away public locations. A few of the occasions recognized confirmed incidents that appeared to fall into multiple of those classes.
You may view the complete dataset right here.
It is very important word that the complete context of an incident could also be unclear from movies on social media alone. Bystanders typically solely start filming when an arrest is already ongoing, for instance, which may make it tough to find out what occurred within the moments earlier than pressure was utilized. Every of the occasions included in our dataset have been verified to have taken place in Illinois in current weeks with at the least two sources – movies taken by totally different folks, native reporting or statements from the Division of Homeland Safety (DHS).
The DHS – which oversees Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) in addition to the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) – has justified the usage of pressure or riot management weapons by saying that protesters have been threatening or attacking brokers.
Bellingcat requested DHS whether or not it had any response to the TRO or allegations that brokers had violated the TRO. As of publication, DHS has not responded to a number of requests for remark.
Assist Bellingcat
Your donations straight contribute to our capability to publish groundbreaking investigations and uncover wrongdoing all over the world.
The TRO does say that riot management weapons or pressure could also be deployed in circumstances equivalent to the place there may be an “fast risk” of bodily hurt to the brokers or others, a number of warnings have been given, or the place “needed and proportional” for an arrest. We didn’t embody movies the place it was apparent that such circumstances had been met.
Regardless of the constraints, movies taken by eyewitnesses are sometimes the one proof of such incidents, which is probably not reported by media or might have concluded by the point journalists attain the scene.
Riot Management Weapons
In our evaluation, we discovered movies exhibiting the usage of riot management weapons equivalent to tear gasoline, pepper spray and different less-lethal weapons in seven occasions the place protesters gave the impression to be posing no seen risk within the footage, and the place no audible warnings gave the impression to be given.
Amongst its provisions, the TRO prohibits the usage of a majority of these weapons on folks “who are usually not posing a right away risk to the protection of a legislation enforcement officer or others” and likewise in circumstances the place utilizing them on supposed targets would lead to harm to those that aren’t posing any risk.
One in all these movies captured the second Bovino threw what regarded like a tear gasoline canister in the course of the Oct. 23 clashes within the Little Village neighbourhood, throughout an operation the place eight folks have been arrested, together with a 16-year-old US citizen. Bovino and DHS have stated that he was hit on the pinnacle by objects thrown by protesters earlier than he threw the tear gasoline canister.
DHS posted a video on Fb, claiming that it was proof that “the usage of chemical munitions was performed in full accordance with CBP coverage and was needed to make sure the protection of each legislation enforcement and the general public”.
The video confirmed a rock skidding on the bottom behind Bovino, however didn’t present the second that it allegedly hit the Border Patrol chief on the pinnacle. A protester who filmed the encounter has additionally reportedly disputed that Bovino was hit.
On the similar protests, one other agent allegedly shot a protester within the neck at shut vary with less-lethal ammunition.
Tear gasoline was additionally deployed on Oct. 12 in Albany Park, Oct. 14 within the East Aspect of Chicago, Oct. 24 in Lakeview and Oct. 25 in Avondale. Bellingcat reviewed footage of every of those incidents and couldn’t see threats to the brokers’ security within the movies earlier than tear gasoline was deployed, or that audible warnings have been issued throughout the footage.
Movies we reviewed additionally confirmed different varieties of riot-control weapons talked about within the TRO. One other video from the Oct. 23 protests in Little Village, posted by a protester named Enrique Bahena, reveals an agent taking pictures a less-lethal projectile straight on the individual filming. An Oct. 26 court docket submitting stated Bahena was shot within the “neck from 5 toes away with a pepper ball”.
Bellingcat’s evaluation of the video, which seems to be the identical one proven in screengrabs in the court docket submitting, discovered that the video in truth reveals the agent deploying a B&T GL-06 40mm launcher, which can be utilized to launch chemical irritant rounds such because the one seen within the video.
Bahena stated in an interview with native outlet Chicago Block Membership that brokers didn’t give warnings earlier than they shot him “within the throat” and threw gasoline canisters on the group of protesters who have been shouting at them to go away. He additionally stated within the interview that protesters did throw objects at brokers, however that this was after brokers had already used pressure.
B&T technical specs for his or her 40mm projectiles state that “pictures to the pinnacle, neck, backbone, or coronary heart are to be averted until deadly pressure is justified”, and advise customers to intention on the waistline.
A DHS Workplace of Inspector Basic Report in 2021 states that “ICE’s use of pressure coverage signifies that the 40MM launcher is lethal pressure when fired at somebody, whereas the CBP use of pressure coverage solely directs officers to not goal an individual’s head or neck”. Throughout this similar occasion in Little Village, movies present different officers showing to fireside less-lethal weapons in the direction of protestors.
The TRO restricts the usage of Compressed Air Launchers or Munitions Launchers equivalent to 40mm launchers to strike an individual, together with on the neck, until they pose an “fast risk of inflicting critical bodily harm or loss of life”.
In one other incident on Oct. 22, an agent appeared to shortly roll down a window and spray what gave the impression to be a chemical irritant at protesters who have been confronting federal officers close to a Sam’s Membership retailer within the Cicero neighbourhood of Chicago.
The incident was captured in two separate livestreams, which present a couple of protesters close to an unmarked darkish gray Chevrolet Tahoe with no entrance licence plate. One of many protesters faucets on the window of the automobile. Somebody then rolls down the window and sprays what seems to be a liquid in a short time earlier than rolling the window again up because the automobile leaves the scene. One of many folks filming stated within the publish for the livestream that this was pepper spray, though Bellingcat was unable to confirm this.
DHS didn’t reply to Bellingcat’s questions on whether or not it believed that the usage of riot-control weapons – together with in the course of the Oct. 23 Little Village protests – was justified primarily based on the phrases of the TRO.
Use of Power
Bellingcat additionally reviewed a number of movies of brokers utilizing pressure in arrests that gave the impression to be associated to Operation Halfway Blitz, and recognized these the place the pressure proven getting used regarded probably extreme and the individual being arrested didn’t seem to pose an “fast risk of bodily hurt to others” – a requirement within the TRO for utilizing pressure equivalent to tackling or shoving somebody to the bottom.
On Oct. 10, a day after the TRO was issued, an ICE agent was seen dragging a teenage woman out of a automobile in Chicago’s Hoffman Estates and tackling her to the bottom whereas she shouted “I’m not resisting”. {The teenager}, reportedly an 18-year-old US citizen, was handcuffed and an officer appeared to place a knee on her again. DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin stated in a publish that the incident was a “housebreaking” arrest from 2024 which didn’t contain ICE – though this has been debunked by a number of information retailers.
Bellingcat requested DHS about this particular incident and why McLaughlin’s publish stays up on X regardless of a number of information retailers verifying that the incident befell this month in Hoffman Estates, however didn’t obtain a response.
This was not the one case the place DHS’ model of occasions seems to contradict video footage of the incident posted on social media.
On Oct. 22, a lady recognized by DHS as Isabel Mata was arrested by Border Patrol brokers in Little Village. A video of the incident reveals a number of brokers tackling her whereas one among them has his knee on her again to carry her to the bottom. DHS acknowledged Mata “threatened a legislation enforcement officer after stating she would put successful out on Chief Gregory Bovino”. Bellingcat reviewed a video that confirmed the minutes earlier than Mata was tackled by brokers however didn’t hear any risk being made, despite the fact that Mata appeared to have been standing close to the individual filming. DHS didn’t reply to Bellingcat’s questions on this incident.
One other video from Oct. 10 seems to indicate brokers colliding with a automobile on Hubbard Road and dragging the driving force out by her legs. The lady, recognized as Dayanne Figueroa, advised Newsweek that she was on her option to get espresso earlier than work and “as an alternative of dealing with the scenario as a routine visitors incident”, masked armed brokers forcibly eliminated her with out questions or informing that she was beneath arrest.
DHS reportedly advised Newsweek that Border Patrol was making a focused arrest when Figueroa’s automobile blocked brokers and struck an unmarked authorities automobile. Additionally they stated she “violently resisted” and was arrested for assault on a federal agent.
The video reveals brokers arresting somebody, earlier than one among their automobiles swerves into one other lane and seems to hit Figueroa’s automobile. A number of bystanders will be heard shouting that the brokers hit Figueroa’s automobile first and that they have been making a U-turn in the midst of the road.
Bellingcat requested DHS in regards to the circumstances beneath which it will take into account the usage of pressure – equivalent to tackling or shoving folks to the bottom – proportionate and needed, however didn’t obtain a response.
Dispersal Orders
The TRO prohibits federal brokers from “issuing a crowd dispersal order requiring any individual to go away a public place that they lawfully have a proper to be, until dispersal is justified by exigent circumstances as outlined by Division of Homeland Safety Use of Power Coverage”.
Bellingcat has requested DHS about when brokers are justified in telling folks to get off the streets, or folks in vehicles to cease following them, and whether or not there are any legal guidelines stopping folks from following or filming federal brokers from a distance. As of publication, we’ve not obtained a response.
Nonetheless, we discovered a number of examples of brokers telling folks to go away public locations when they didn’t seem like impeding arrests in video footage.
In a video recorded in Chicago’s Arlington Heights on Oct. 24, a masked man with a rifle tells somebody filming to “get the f*** throughout the road” and “get again to your automobile”. The individual filming is shouting that brokers have assaulted a lady and slapped her cellphone out of her palms, and the video seems to indicate a lady in a scuffle with one other masked agent, apparently over a cellphone. A separate video from the identical location and date reveals brokers arresting a person who’s on the bottom.
In a few of these circumstances, brokers seem like pointing non-lethal weapons at civilians whereas ordering them to go away public areas. A video from Oct. 16 reveals brokers telling protesters to “get out of the road”, pointing pepper spray at them and threatening them with arrest in Chicago’s Evanston neighbourhood.
The same incident befell in Rolling Meadows on Oct. 19 when an officer was pictured pointing a pepper ball gun from a transferring automobile at an individual filming him in a parking zone. A federal decide reportedly stated the incident was “troubling” and has known as for solutions.
On Oct. 20, in Berwyn, an agent pointed a gun at a lady who stated she was pregnant. By the girl’s account, the brokers have been chasing after two folks and the video reveals her honking to alert these close by. A DHS agent advised Newsweek that the agent “acted to guard his life and security of others round him and confirmed nice restraint”.
DHS didn’t reply to Bellingcat’s questions in regards to the circumstances beneath which its brokers have been justified in telling folks to get off the streets or folks in vehicles to cease following them.
Choose Ellis’ TRO is ready to run out on Nov. 6. There’s a scheduled listening to the day prior, Nov. 5, to find out if the TRO ought to be transformed right into a preliminary injunction.
Pooja Chaudhuri, Kolina Koltai, Youri van der Weide, Sebastian Vandermeersch, Melissa Zhu and Trevor Ball contributed analysis to this piece, alongside Fraser Crichton, Olivia Gresham, Bonny Albo and Vladimir Zaha from Bellingcat’s World Authentication Mission.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the power to hold out our work relies on the sort help of particular person donors. If you need to help our work, you are able to do so right here. You can too subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our Publication and comply with us on Twitter right here and Mastodon right here.
