NEED TO KNOW
-
In October 1994, South Carolina mom Susan Smith claimed {that a} Black man had carjacked her and kidnapped her youngsters
-
Days later, she confessed that she’d let her automobile roll right into a lake with sons Michael, 3, and Alexander, 14 months, inside
-
She started serving a life sentence for the murders one yr later and was denied parole in November 2024
Thirty-one years after Susan Smith confessed to the homicide of her two younger youngsters, she continues to serve a life sentence in jail.
Smith, a younger South Carolina mom, claimed a Black man had carjacked her and had taken off along with her two toddlers within the automobile in October 1994. Nevertheless, simply 9 days later, Smith confessed that there had been no carjacking. In actuality, she had pushed her automobile to an area boat ramp and let it roll right into a lake — along with her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, strapped inside.
Smith’s alleged motive for the murders was that she was secretly relationship an area businessman, Tom Findlay, who didn’t need youngsters. In an effort to avoid wasting their relationship, Smith drowned her two younger sons. However Smith — who has been serving a life sentence for the killings since 1995 — insists that she is misunderstood.
“I’m not the monster society thinks I’m. I’m removed from it,” she wrote in a 2015 letter to The State, a South Carolina newspaper. “One thing went very unsuitable that night time. I used to be not myself. I used to be a superb mom and I cherished my boys. There was no motive because it was not even a deliberate occasion. I used to be not in my proper thoughts.”
After almost 30 years behind bars, Smith was set to be eligible for parole on Nov. 4, 2024, however she was denied.
From her life behind bars to being denied parole, right here’s the whole lot to find out about the place Susan Smith is now.
She has been serving a life sentence since July 1995
Dave Martin/AP
Homicide defendent Susan Smith departs the Union County Courthouse in Union, S.C., on Wednesday, July 19, 1995
Smith got here clear about killing her two youngsters 9 days after their homicide, and on Nov. 4, 1994, their our bodies had been recovered.
Smith’s homicide trial started in July 1995. The prosecution sought the dying penalty and alleged that it was Smith’s need for a relationship with Findlay — who didn’t need youngsters — that led her to kill her two sons.
The protection, nevertheless, portrayed Smith as a lady with psychological sickness who meant to kill herself and her youngsters on the night time of Oct. 25, 1994 — however saved herself on the final second, in accordance with The New York Occasions.
The trial lasted lower than every week, and the jury took lower than two and a half hours to search out Smith responsible on two counts of first-degree homicide, The New York Occasions reported. Nevertheless, the jury declined to offer Smith the dying penalty — as an alternative sentencing her to life in jail. Smith, who was 23 on the time, could be eligible for parole 30 years later, in 2024, in accordance with The Washington Submit.
“All of us felt like Susan was a very disturbed individual,” juror Deborah Benvenuti informed reporters. “And all of us felt that giving her the dying penalty wouldn’t serve justice.”
Nevertheless, the boys’ father, David Smith, informed reporters on the courthouse that he didn’t really feel justice had been served.
“I’ll always remember what Susan has performed and I’ll always remember Michael and Alex. Me and my household after all are dissatisfied that the dying penalty wasn’t the decision,” he stated.
Two jail guards had been charged with having intercourse with Smith
Smith started her life sentence on the Camille Griffin Graham Correctional Establishment in Columbia, S.C. Throughout her time at that jail, she obtained two infractions for having intercourse with jail guards.
The incidents had been found in 2000, when Smith was 28. Based on UPI, 50-year-old jail guard Houston Cagle had had intercourse with Smith not less than 4 occasions. An investigator found the affair whereas trying into tabloid claims that Smith had been crushed. Cagle pleaded responsible and was fired. He spent three months in jail and Smith was disciplined.
In September 2000, a jail captain named Alfred Rowe was arrested for having intercourse with Smith, in accordance with ABC Information. Their encounter got here to mild after Smith informed investigators she had intercourse with Rowe and he confessed. A yr later, Rowe pleaded responsible and obtained 5 years probation.
Because of the sexual infractions, Smith was transferred to the Leath Correctional Establishment in Greenwood, S.C. Jail guards there took particular precautions with Smith in mild of her previous, by no means permitting her to be alone with considered one of them and sometimes transporting further prisoners along with her.
“Nobody trusts her to be alone with a guard,” a jail supply informed PEOPLE. “She spends most of her time in her cell or working her job, however when she’s being transported, there are at all times two guards along with her, ideally a male and a feminine.”
She has been in bother for drug use and self-mutilation whereas in jail
South Carolina Division of Corrections Susan Smith in jail
Smith’s disciplinary points continued at Leath Correctional Institute. Jailhouse data present that Smith was disciplined not less than 5 occasions between 2010 and 2017 for infractions together with self-mutilation, drug use and possession of narcotics or marijuana. Punishment for her infractions concerned the lack of visitation, canteen and phone privileges.
She was disciplined on drug expenses twice in 2010 and as soon as in 2015 and misplaced privileges for greater than a yr because of this. Rowe, one of many jail guards who had intercourse with Smith, claimed that her drug use escalated when she was transferred to Leath.
“She might now not get the male consideration that she used as a drug,” he claimed in an episode of Lifetime’s Cellmate Secrets and techniques in July 2021.
Christie Smith, Smith’s former cellmate, revealed that her “most important objective was to deliver her her tablets.”
“I’ve seen Susan do the whole lot,” she alleged, in reference to Smith’s drug use. “Snort, booty bump, swallow, shoot. I’ve seen her do all of it.”
She had a long-distance boyfriend from behind bars
In March 2022, PEOPLE realized that Smith — who was then 50 years previous and had spent greater than half her life in jail — had been sending “romantic correspondence” to a person exterior of the jail for over a yr.
The lengthy distance romance started after the person — who was divorced, in his mid-40s and had two grownup youngsters — noticed a documentary about Smith on tv. He wrote her a letter, and their correspondence finally grew to “just a few letters per week,” a supply informed PEOPLE.
“They write letters on a regular basis,” a member of the family of Smith’s informed PEOPLE. “Handwritten letters about what their future will probably be. She’s very romantic like that, at all times desirous to discover a fortunately ever after.”
Smith wrote about desirous to “begin recent” along with her boyfriend if she had been ever free of jail. “We’re going to have superb chemistry in individual,” she wrote in a single letter seen by PEOPLE. “I can’t wait to construct a life with you. Depart the previous errors behind and begin recent, simply you and me.”
A relative of Smith’s informed PEOPLE that the couple had been even discussing marriage if she acquired parole in 2024.
“She’s imagining the normalcy of a married life,” the relative informed PEOPLE. “She needs the whole lot in life that she believes has handed her by. So yeah, she is speaking marriage with him and pondering that she will spend the final a part of her life as a spouse and stepmother.”
By October 2022, nevertheless, the connection had “fizzled out.” A Smith member of the family informed PEOPLE, “They’re now not corresponding. It’s over.”
She was eligible for parole in November 2024
Dave Martin/AP Susan Smith appears to be like towards an unidentified legislation enforcement officer as she departs the Union County Courthouse in Union, SC., on Friday, July 14, 1995.
Smith was reportedly targeted on turning round her habits in jail with the hopes of being granted parole in November 2024. A jail supply who had identified Smith for a number of years informed PEOPLE in 2020 that Smith was following jail guidelines to assist higher her probabilities at launch.
“She’s behaving herself lately,” the supply stated. “She is aware of that her parole date is 4 years away and she will’t get parole if she is not being good.”
Nevertheless, Smith’s disciplinary historical past — which incorporates her infractions for drug use, self-mutilation and sexual contact with a guard — would additionally issue into the parole board’s determination. Finally, Smith was denied parole, regardless of telling the board at her listening to that she is aware of “what I did was horrible.”
“I’m a Christian and God is a giant a part of my life and I do know he has forgiven me and I do know that’s by his grace and mercy … And I simply ask that you just present that very same type of mercy as nicely,” she stated, as reported by CNN.
Now that Smith has handed the 30-year mark of her sentence, she is eligible for parole each two years, that means the subsequent listening to will probably be in November 2026.
Her ex-husband David stated he’ll do “the whole lot in my energy” to maintain her behind bars
Earlier than she murdered their youngsters, Smith had already filed for divorce from David in September 1994. A decide granted their divorce in Could 1995, a few months earlier than her trial started.
Two months forward of her parole listening to, Smith’s ex-husband David shared on Court docket TV in September 2024 what he would say to his former spouse in the event that they got here head to head.
“I might simply inform her that you haven’t any thought of how a lot harm you’ve gotten performed to so many individuals,” he stated. “I might inform her that in my capabilities I will do the whole lot in my energy to ensure you keep behind bars.”
David has since moved on from the connection, welcoming two extra youngsters, Savannah and Nicolas, in 2001 and 2003, respectively, per Go Upstate.
“I’ve stated earlier than, I admit being a awful husband,” David informed the outlet in a June 2004 interview. “However I’ve at all times been a superb father to my children. I get pleasure from being a father very a lot. I imply there is no better love on this planet than loving a baby.”
At her November 2024 parole listening to, David requested the board to disclaim her, saying that Smith serving 30 years was “simply not sufficient.”
“This wasn’t a tragic mistake … She purposely meant to finish their life,” he stated, in accordance with ABC Information. “I’ve by no means felt any regret from her for it.”
David added, “I will probably be right here each two years going ahead to make sure that their dying does not go in useless.”
Throughout a February 2025 Dateline episode, David appeared again on the second that Smith admitted to drowning their sons.
“She simply casually, such as you and I sitting right here, stated ‘I’m sorry.’ And that was about so far as it went,” he stated, including, “I requested her ‘Why did you do that? Why?’ And he or she stated, ‘I don’t know why, however I’m sorry.’ ”
Learn the unique article on Individuals
