By Alex Brown, Stateline.org
As President Donald Trump wages an all-out assault on offshore wind tasks, state leaders face a dilemma: Do they pull the plug on offshore wind and search for different methods to satisfy their fast-growing power wants? Or do they double down on their investments, in hopes of serving to the business rebound after Trump leaves workplace?
Many states alongside the East Coast have been relying on offshore wind to offer a big portion of their electrical energy wants within the many years forward. They’ve invested billions of {dollars} in rising the business and getting tasks off the bottom.
However offshore wind has a specific vulnerability: The federal authorities is the owner.
Almost all offshore wind tasks are greater than 3 miles offshore, in ocean waters managed by federal businesses. That provides Trump a way more direct path to blocking such tasks than for onshore wind and photo voltaic tasks on non-public lands. Already, he has finished extra to stymie offshore wind than many observers thought was doable, together with an order to cease work on a wind farm off Rhode Island that was practically full.
“This is without doubt one of the few areas the place states usually are not in full management of their very own power future,” mentioned New York state Sen. Andrew Gounardes, a Democrat. “This administration is all the time on the lookout for leverage factors to attempt to squeeze, and this can be a weak one for us.”
State leaders usually are not but backing away from their commitments to offshore wind, saying it nonetheless has huge long-term potential. However they acknowledge Trump has proven the business’s vulnerability to political interference, which might scare away buyers and builders.
For now, lawmakers say their offshore wind plans have had an enormous setback, one that might threaten grid reliability and drive up power payments. Whereas some state leaders have filed lawsuits difficult Trump’s orders, some say they could want to start out trying to different power sources if offshore wind stalls out.
Since he took workplace, Trump has halted leases for brand spanking new wind tasks, canceled $679 million in funding to help manufacturing and ports, ended clear power tax credit and introduced plans to cancel the approval of a Maryland offshore wind mission.
Most drastically, Trump final month ordered crews to cease work on Revolution Wind, a mission off the coast of Rhode Island that’s 80% full. Trade leaders say the order to desert an almost completed mission was unprecedented. Dozens of generators have already got been erected, with others staged at a close-by pier. Greater than 50 employees had been taken off their deliberate two-week shift putting in new generators, the CT Mirror reported. One development crew with about 20 members was left stranded at sea, unable to work, in line with The Wall Avenue Journal.
“That is very a lot additional than was deemed doable or practical,” mentioned Sam Salustro, senior vp of coverage and market affairs with Oceantic Community, an business lobbying group. “The self-destruction is past our scope of creativeness in the beginning of the 12 months.
It’s an enormous quantity of energy that’s simply being held again by the federal authorities.”
State and business leaders have filed lawsuits looking for to complete work on the Revolution Wind mission, arguing Trump has overstepped his authority.
Whereas 5 East Coast offshore wind farms are within the development section, dozens extra tasks are nonetheless within the planning and allowing levels. States have been relying on these tasks to energy thousands and thousands of properties, however these plans have hit a useless finish with Trump within the White Home. What’s much less clear is whether or not the business can outlast Trump and bounce again after he leaves workplace.
“[Trump’s actions] are designed to create a lot uncertainty and danger that the business doesn’t rebound underneath a unique administration,” mentioned Timothy Fox, managing director at ClearView Vitality Companions LLC, an unbiased analysis agency. “Even when a future administration makes an attempt to revive offshore wind improvement, builders and financiers are prone to be cautious of investing in a sector with lengthy lead instances and such demonstrable election dangers.”
Trump has lengthy opposed offshore wind, repeating false claims that it harms whales, is unreliable and drives up power prices. His opposition appeared to originate with the development of an offshore wind farm close to his golf course in Scotland, which he deemed an eyesore.
The White Home didn’t reply to a Stateline interview request.
State plans
For a lot of East Coast states, offshore wind has grow to be a crucial piece of their power plans. With restricted areas on land which are suited to large-scale power improvement, lawmakers have turned to sea-based tasks — which additionally supply the benefit of robust ocean winds. State leaders say such tasks might harness huge quantities of energy, which is urgently wanted as information facilities and synthetic intelligence drive up electrical energy calls for.
In whole, eight East Coast states have dedicated to constructing greater than 45 gigawatts of offshore wind power by 2040 — sufficient to energy greater than 30 million properties.
Some states have invested closely in overhauling ports, constructing factories and creating workforce improvement packages to assist the business get on its toes. Officers say the younger business is already creating 1000’s of producing jobs and reviving coastal economies.
However now that progress has come to a crashing halt.
The Revolution Wind mission within the federal waters off Rhode Island had been anticipated to offer greater than 700 megawatts of electrical energy beginning subsequent 12 months, representing about 2.5% of the ability throughout New England.
Trump’s order to cease work on the Revolution Wind mission invoked unspecified “nationwide safety pursuits,” with Inside Secretary Doug Burgum later claiming that undersea drones might escape radar detection by attacking by way of a wind farm. Offshore wind builders famous that the mission already acquired in depth evaluations and approvals from the Division of Protection and different businesses.
Canceling the mission might threaten the reliability of the area’s energy grid, New England’s grid operator, ISO New England, mentioned in an announcement final month.
“I’m actually involved that the cancellation or delay of this mission might trigger a spike in power market prices and an influence to the reliability of the grid,” Katie Dykes, commissioner of Connecticut’s Division of Vitality & Environmental Safety, instructed Stateline. “There aren’t simply different tasks within the works that may be swapped in.”
Dykes mentioned Trump’s order has made buyers hesitant to help different power tasks, given Trump’s try and halt Revolution Wind even after years of planning, allowing and development.
The attorneys common in Connecticut and Rhode Island have joined mission builders in suing the Trump administration, hoping to pressure the completion of the mission.
Final week, Burgum mentioned his company can be “taking a deep look” on the 5 wind farms already underneath development, CNBC reported, blaming an “ideologically pushed allowing course of” that allowed them to maneuver ahead. Whereas threatening these tasks, he additionally mentioned the administration is “underneath dialogue” with the governors of Rhode Island and Connecticut about permitting work to proceed on Revolution Wind.
Trump’s administration beforehand issued a stop-work order in April for the Empire Wind 1 offshore mission in New York, however relented the next month and allowed development to proceed. That reversal appeared to observe a cope with Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul to construct a gasoline pipeline in New York, Politico reported.
However Trump’s refusal to subject new permits has halted different pending tasks in New York state, mentioned Gounardes, the state senator, making it inconceivable for the state to achieve its goal of 9 gigawatts by 2035. Hochul’s latest push for extra nuclear energy, he mentioned, is probably going a pivot to different types of power with out carbon emissions.
Not giving up
In the meantime, Trump’s administration has signaled that it’ll revoke permits for a Maryland mission that has not but began development. State leaders in Maryland have dedicated to constructing 8.5 gigawatts of offshore wind by 2035. With Trump’s delays, that timeline is now out of attain, mentioned Democratic state Del. Lorig Charkoudian, who authored the legislation setting that focus on.
For now, she mentioned, state leaders ought to give attention to constructing transmission infrastructure, enabling offshore wind to hook up with the grid shortly if a brand new administration permits tasks to maneuver ahead.
“No one’s giving up,” Charkoudian mentioned. “Offshore wind is crucial to our power future. There’s nonetheless numerous work for our states to be doing so we’re forward of the sport after we lastly get sanity again in Washington.”
Earlier this month, the Democratic governors of Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York and Rhode Island issued a joint assertion praising the business’s increase to the manufacturing sector and calling on Trump to uphold federal permits which were issued for offshore wind tasks.
However some state leaders are frightened concerning the business’s viability.
“[Trump’s actions] might be an enormous blow,” mentioned Massachusetts state Sen. Jamie Eldridge, a Democrat who has sponsored laws to help the deployment of offshore wind. “It will likely be arduous to get better from. It received’t simply be, ‘Right here’s a Democratic president restoring every little thing.’”
Trade analysts famous that tasks can take practically a decade to finish. Even underneath a pleasant administration, buyers and builders might now be hesitant to sink billions of {dollars} into tasks that may be abruptly canceled if the following president doesn’t like them.
Eldridge mentioned Massachusetts is embracing all types of renewable power, together with photo voltaic and hydropower from Canada. If offshore wind is delayed, he mentioned, leaders might must give attention to power effectivity and lowering energy consumption.
Virginia leaders have dedicated to constructing 5.2 gigawatts of offshore wind tasks by the top of 2034. That aim will likely be “desperately arduous to satisfy,” mentioned state Sen. Creigh Deeds, a Democrat who chairs the Commerce and Labor Committee.
“If I had been an investor, I would definitely be frightened about [the future of offshore wind],” he mentioned.
Deeds mentioned it’s too quickly to say whether or not Virginia might want to alter its power planning, particularly because it offers with an inflow of information facilities which are driving up electrical energy demand. He mentioned lawmakers at the moment are extra targeted on Trump’s cuts to meals stamps and Medicaid.
Whereas some state leaders say their timelines for offshore wind will now be inconceivable to satisfy, none have publicly backed away from their long-term objectives.
Trade leaders say there’s a lot that states could be doing now to assist the business rebound after Trump leaves workplace.
“If now we have to attend the following three years, there’s numerous work that may be finished on the state facet,” mentioned Alicia Gené Artessa, director of the New York Offshore Wind Alliance, an business group.
She known as on states to proceed constructing transmission infrastructure to coastal areas and investing in workforce improvement packages for offshore wind.
Salustro, with the Oceantic Community, famous that many Republicans have embraced offshore wind and the roles it has created. The present battle over offshore wind is essentially pushed by “one particular person’s persona,” he mentioned, giving him hope the business can outlast Trump.
“The essential economics are going to prevail long run,” he mentioned.
Regardless of their misgivings, many state lawmakers largely share that view.
“It’s too early to drag the plug on the way forward for offshore wind,” mentioned Gounardes, the New York senator. “The wind is all the time going to blow regardless of who’s president, and we needs to be poised to make the most of that in order that when the administration modifications, we’re not a decade behind.”
Stateline reporter Alex Brown could be reached at abrown@stateline.org.
©2025 States Newsroom. Go to at stateline.org. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
