By Jonathan Shorman, Stateline.org
Derrin Robinson has labored in Oregon elections for greater than 30 years, lengthy sufficient to recollect when voters within the state solid their ballots at bodily polling websites as an alternative of by mail.
Because the nonpartisan clerk of Harney County, an enormous, rural expanse bigger than Massachusetts, Robinson oversees elections with about 6,000 registered voters. Oregon has completely performed elections by mail since 2000, a system he thinks works nicely, requires fewer employees and doesn’t power voters to journey via treacherous climate to succeed in a polling place.
“As you’ll be able to inform, I’m not an advocate for going again,” Robinson stated.
Not everybody agrees. An Oregon Republican lawmaker has launched laws to finish the state’s mail voting legislation, and organizers of a poll measure marketing campaign searching for to ban mail-in voting say they’ve gathered hundreds of signatures.
Throughout the US, voting by mail faces a second of uncertainty forward of the midterm elections subsequent 12 months.
President Donald Trump has assailed mail-in voting and vowed this summer time to guide a motion to get rid of the follow, selling baseless claims that mailed ballots are linked to widespread fraud. Some states are additionally reevaluating their mail-in voting legal guidelines, together with shortening or ending grace intervals that now require election officers to depend mailed ballots that arrive after Election Day.
The U.S. Supreme Court docket in November agreed to take a case that might finish poll grace intervals nationwide. A choice by the justices late subsequent spring or early summer time putting them down might have an effect on 16 states and the District of Columbia, probably upending the principles of elections as states put together to carry primaries forward of the November midterm elections that may decide management of Congress.
Mail-in voting surged in 2020 amid the COVID-19 pandemic, when 43% of voters solid their votes by mail. The proportion of voters mailing their ballots has fallen from that peak however stays above pre-pandemic ranges. About 30% of voters solid mail ballots in 2024, based on information gathered by the U.S. Election Help Fee.
That’s 46.8 million voters, underscoring the electoral and political stakes concerned in any main change to mail-in voting.
“THE MAIL-IN BALLOT HOAX, USING VOTING MACHINES THAT ARE A COMPLETE AND TOTAL DISASTER, MUST END, NOW!!!” Trump posted in August on his social media website, Reality Social.
Trump promised within the submit to challenge an govt order that might deliver “HONESTY” to the midterm elections, however none has been forthcoming. In response to questions, the White Home referred Stateline again to the president’s submit.
Robinson, the president of the Oregon Affiliation of County Clerks, emphasised the safety of mail-in ballots, however acknowledged that the message has turn out to be a “arduous promote.”
“We’ve carried out all the things in our energy to attempt to squash the myths and disinformation that it’s wrought with fraud, as a result of it’s not,” he stated.
Poll deadlines focused
Amid scrutiny of mail-in ballots, Ohio is on the verge of eliminating its poll grace interval, probably turning into at the least the fifth state to tighten poll arrival deadlines this 12 months, together with Kansas, Minnesota, North Dakota and Utah.
The Republican-controlled Ohio legislature final month handed a invoice that might require all ballots to be returned to election officers by the shut of polls on Election Day to depend, with exceptions for late-arriving army and abroad ballots. Beneath present legislation, the ballots should arrive by the fourth day after the election.
Ohio Republican Secretary of State Frank LaRose spearheaded the push for the change. He has argued that setting an Election Day deadline for the arrival of mailed ballots will decrease voter confusion and that uncertainty surrounding late-arriving ballots in a detailed contest dangers damaging voter confidence.
LaRose has additionally urged the U.S. Division of Justice would sue Ohio if it didn’t change its deadline.
Throughout a legislative listening to in late October, LaRose informed lawmakers that Assistant U.S. Lawyer Common Harmeet Dhillon, who leads the Justice Division’s Civil Rights Division, wrote in a Sept. 29 letter to Ohio Lawyer Common Dave Yost that Ohio ought to take quick motion to adjust to federal legislation and “keep away from expensive litigation” in federal court docket.
“They recognized what they think about to be a battle between state and federal legislation as to the deadline for which absentee ballots have to be returned by mail,” LaRose testified
The Justice Division indicated that Ohio legislation ought to match that of different states that require ballots to be returned by the shut of polls on Election Day, LaRose stated. He added that he requested for the chance to work with lawmakers to alter the legislation in lieu of a lawsuit.
LaRose’s workplace didn’t reply to Stateline’s interview request. The Justice Division and Yost didn’t reply to requests for remark and for a duplicate of the September letter.
Ohio Republican Gov. Mike DeWine hasn’t stated whether or not he’ll signal or veto the invoice eliminating the grace interval. A spokesperson for the governor stated Monday that DeWine hadn’t but obtained it.
In the course of the 2024 election in Ohio, 8,335 mail ballots weren’t counted, or 0.8% of all mail ballots returned to election officers, based on the U.S. Election Help Fee. Nationwide, 584,463 mail ballots weren’t counted, 1.2% of these returned.
Almost 18% of rejected mail ballots had been rejected as a result of they weren’t obtained on time, based on the fee’s information.
Debra Shankland, a 66-year-old Democrat within the Cleveland suburb of Brecksville, stated she’s labored to register voters in public housing and different condominium buildings, giving her expertise speaking with individuals about voting by mail. Many individuals like mail ballots, she stated, however wish to drop them off as an alternative of mailing them.
Shankland, who submitted written testimony to the state legislature opposing the elimination of Ohio’s grace interval, wrote that she votes absentee as a result of she’s a ballot employee and subsequently unavailable on Election Day. As a substitute, she locations her poll in a drop field (Ohio legislation limits drop bins to at least one per county).
“I do know lots of people are very leery of the mail and I’m, too,” Shankland stated in an interview, including that she’s had mail stolen previously.
The US Postal Service has battled declining efficiency for years. Forward of the 2020 election, then-Postmaster Common Louis DeJoy rolled out a collection of adjustments to mail service, together with the removing of some mail-sorting machines and cuts to the variety of the service’s ubiquitous blue public mailboxes. Amid criticism, DeJoy backed off the adjustments a couple of months earlier than the election; he resigned earlier this 12 months.
Throughout peak mail season final 12 months — Thanksgiving via New Yr’s Eve — USPS missed 5 of six service efficiency targets, regardless of reducing the targets, based on a USPS Workplace of Inspector Common report launched in July.
However the postal service has touted its efforts to make sure fast supply of election mail, together with ballots, in the course of the 2024 election. USPS has stated it delivered 99.88% of ballots to election officers inside seven days, and 97.73% of ballots inside three days. A USPS Workplace of Inspector Common report from April discovered that the postal service “considerably exceeded service efficiency objectives” for election mail and most political mail.
USPS has beforehand famous that election legal guidelines and procedures differ among the many 50 states and the practically 8,000 election jurisdictions within the nation. “This may end up in a mismatch of timeframes, deadlines, poll return solutions and the sensible actuality of utilizing the mail,” the postal service stated in a November 2024 report.
Supreme Court docket case looms
The U.S. Supreme Court docket might quickly set a nationwide mail poll arrival deadline.
The court docket will think about a dispute between the Republican Nationwide Committee and Mississippi, which requires mailed ballots to be counted if they’re obtained inside 5 enterprise days of the election and are postmarked on or earlier than Election Day. Postmarks act as a verify towards fraud, serving to to make sure that ballots had been positioned within the mail earlier than the top of the election — and never afterward in an try to change the result.
The case cuts throughout partisan traces. Mississippi Secretary of State Michael Watson, a Republican who’s defending the legislation, declined to remark, citing pending litigation. However in September, Watson informed the Mississippi newspaper The Dispatch that “the coverage choice must be made on the state degree.”
On the core of the case is a query of whether or not a longstanding federal legislation that units the Tuesday after the primary Monday in November as Election Day for federal places of work, preempts state legal guidelines that permit ballots solid by Election Day, however obtained later, to depend.
And on the identical time, the case asks: What does it imply to solid a poll? Is placing it within the mail sufficient, or does it want to succeed in election officers?
The fifth U.S. Circuit Court docket of Appeals dominated in October 2024 that the legislation requires ballots to be obtained by Election Day. Trump likewise issued an govt order in March that tried to require that mail ballots be obtained by the top of Election Day and to impose different election adjustments, however a lot of the order has been blocked by federal courts.
Caleb Hays, chief coverage counsel on the Middle for Election Confidence, a conservative-leaning authorized advocacy group that opposes poll grace intervals, stated Congress has the authority to set the date of congressional and presidential elections and had spoken. The middle has filed court docket papers urging the Supreme Court docket to strike down the Mississippi legislation.
A requirement that every one ballots have to be obtained by the shut of polls units a “vivid line rule” for election officers and voters, Hays stated, ensuring everybody has the identical expectation about when ballots have to be in.
“On this case, Election Day means Election Day,” Hays stated.
In West Virginia, lower than 3% of voters solid their ballots by mail within the 2024 election, based on the U.S. Election Help Fee. Solely 247 mail ballots weren’t counted — 1.1% of the mail ballots obtained by election officers.
Nonetheless, West Virginia Republican Secretary of State Kris Warner stated mail poll arrival deadlines must be left to the states. In his state, ballots postmarked on or earlier than Election Day have to be obtained earlier than the beginning of the canvass. He stated the grace interval is “working simply superb the best way it’s proper now.”
Warner stated he would comply with the legislation as interpreted by the U.S. Supreme Court docket however warned Trump towards trying to unilaterally change election procedures in West Virginia, the place the president loved a virtually 41% margin of victory in 2024.
“You realize, throughout the underside of my state flag is ‘Montani Semper Liberi’ and Mountaineers are all the time free and so they’re not going to take kindly to an govt order by the president altering how we’re going to do our elections,” Warner stated.
Again in Oregon, Robinson, the Harney County clerk, stated he personally wouldn’t thoughts if the grace interval goes away. Oregon at present counts ballots obtained inside seven days of the election in the event that they had been postmarked by Election Day. An increasing number of ballots are arriving in the course of the grace interval, he stated.
“However we do what we’re informed and comply with the Structure,” Robinson stated.
Stateline reporter Jonathan Shorman might be reached at jshorman@stateline.org.
©2025 States Newsroom. Go to at stateline.org. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.
