By MELISSA GOLDIN
The meals pyramid that after guided People’ diets has been retired for greater than a decade, however that has not stopped President Donald Trump’s well being secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., from repeatedly criticizing the idea.
He typically highlights the pyramid, misrepresenting dietary requirements and criticizing well being initiatives of the Biden administration. Such claims have been featured in a video aired Tuesday, earlier than his look on Fox Information’ “Jesse Watters Primetime.”
Right here’s a more in-depth have a look at the information.
KENNEDY: “The dietary tips that we inherited from the Biden administration have been 453 pages lengthy. They have been pushed by the identical business impulses that put Froot Loops on the prime of the meals pyramid.”
THE FACTS: The unique meals pyramid didn’t point out any particular merchandise. However on the very prime, it really helpful that oils, fat and sugar be consumed “sparingly.” Grains reminiscent of bread, cereal, rice and pasta have been on the underside tier, the place six to 11 parts a day have been really helpful. The present dietary tips are 164 pages lengthy, not 453. They have been launched in December 2020 throughout Trump’s first time period, together with a four-page government abstract.
A scientific report used to develop the dietary tips is printed each 5 years by an advisory committee. The newest report, launched in December by the Biden administration, is 421 pages lengthy. Trump’s first administration launched an 835-page scientific report in July 2020 that knowledgeable the present tips.
“The dietary tips embrace a number of paperwork, together with a scientific report which summarizes the scientific proof supporting the dietary tips,” mentioned Laura Bellows, an affiliate professor of dietary sciences at Cornell College. “It may be lengthy as a result of complete nature of the doc. That mentioned, these findings are distilled down into concise tips which are foundational to the creation of shopper info and academic supplies.”
Consultants mentioned that Froot Loops, a breakfast cereal, would have fallen into a number of classes beneath the pyramid idea, providing obscure steering to shoppers.
“It’s a bit trickier than only one grouping,” Bellows mentioned in an e mail. She mentioned Froot Loops “would fall extra in meals that we should always ‘reasonable’ … however does contribute to the grain group.” The cereal is excessive in sugar, she added, however does have fiber and different key vitamins.
The Agriculture Division launched an up to date pyramid information in 2005 that included new dietary requirements. It retired the pyramid thought altogether in 2011 and now makes use of the MyPlate idea, which stresses consuming a wholesome steadiness of various meals primarily based on elements reminiscent of age and intercourse.
MyPlate recommends making half of the grains one eats in a day entire grains and slicing again on added sugars. Just like the meals pyramid, this places Froot Loops, which has entire grains and added sugars, in each classes.
“MyPlate, not the Meals Pyramid, has been the visible graphic for the US Dietary Tips since 2011,” mentioned Bellows. “So, referring to the ‘prime of the pyramid’ is a dated reference.”
Kennedy’s different criticism of Froot Loops has targeted totally on its producer’s use of synthetic dyes to boost its coloration. He has made eliminating synthetic colours in meals an vital half of his “Make America Wholesome Once more” plan.
Requested for touch upon Kennedy’s remarks, the Well being and Human Companies Division mentioned work is on observe to launch the ultimate 2025–2030 Dietary Tips for People.
The company mentioned Kennedy is dedicated to making sure these tips “are grounded in gold-standard science and mirror a transparent deal with wholesome, entire, and nutritious meals.”
Discover AP Truth Checks right here: https://apnews.com/APFactCheck.
Initially Printed:
