The slayings of Hollywood legend Rob Reiner and his photographer spouse, Michele, have given rise to a fancy and intensely watched authorized battle involving their accused son, prosecutors and protection attorneys, who all face key strategic choices within the coming weeks and months.
Prosecutors allege Nick Reiner fatally stabbed his mother and father inside the main bedroom of their Brentwood residence early on a Sunday morning, then fled the realm.
They’ve supplied no motive for the Dec. 14 assault, however Nick Reiner struggled with dependancy for years, and he had been prescribed remedy for schizophrenia in some unspecified time in the future earlier than the killings, based on two sources with data of the legal investigation. Sources have additionally stated he received into some kind of argument with Rob Reiner at a Christmas occasion hours earlier than the slaying.
Authorized consultants say Reiner’s psychological situation and the small print of what occurred on the occasion might be vital parts in the case.
An entire evaluation of his psychological well being will in all probability take months, and the outcomes of that might affect how each side proceed and whether or not prosecutors search the loss of life penalty.
Reiner, 32, was charged with two counts of homicide and will face life in jail with out parole, or the loss of life penalty if convicted of the particular circumstance allegation of a number of murders. Reiner appeared in court docket Dec. 17 sporting a blue suicide prevention smock, which is issued to defendants who pose a threat of self-harm. A choose permitted legal professional Alan Jackson’s request to proceed Reiner’s arraignment to Jan. 7.
Reiner didn’t enter a plea, so the general public has not but heard his aspect of the story. Prosecutors have additionally launched few particulars.
Assessing Nick Reiner’s psychological state
Lou Shapiro, a Los Angeles protection legal professional, stated he expects that Jackson is now working to guage “Reiner’s historical past of psychological well being and frame of mind in the course of the fee of a criminal offense. That’s going to take time for the consultants to arrange a report.”
These findings might be the premise for discussions of a plea deal or the start of an madness protection, based on Shapiro and others.
The brutal killings of the Reiners shocked the world, and the stakes are going to be excessive for Los Angeles County Dist. Atty. Nathan Hochman and his employees, who’ve vowed justice for the beloved couple.
Shapiro stated Hochman is unlikely to think about a punishment lower than life with out the potential for parole, since he has already alleged particular circumstances.
“It’s going to be onerous for him politically to stroll that again,” Shapiro stated.
Neama Rahmani, a former federal prosecutor, agreed however stated he could be stunned if prosecutors sought the loss of life penalty.
“California hasn’t carried out an execution in a long time, and Newsom had positioned a moratorium on the loss of life penalty,” he stated. “It’s nonetheless extremely unlikely that Nick is executed, however the potential for the loss of life penalty could also be utilized by the prosecution to leverage a plea. Extra seemingly, this gained’t be a capital case and it’ll go to trial as a result of the prosecution gained’t provide something lower than life with out the potential for parole.”
The Conan O’Brien occasion struggle might be key
The case is in its earliest levels and prosecutors have introduced little or no proof towards Nick Reiner, together with forensics, movies or different information. So it’s not possible to know exactly what is going to occur subsequent. Prosecutors haven’t commented on the allegation that Rob and Nick Reiner exchanged phrases at Conan O’Brien’s Christmas occasion. Some household buddies instructed The Instances the conflict had been “overblown.”
However Rahmani stated prosecutors may use it.
He stated it might be used as proof of premeditation. “When you get into an argument with somebody and also you come again with a weapon, that’s premeditation.”
Rahmani additionally stated prosecutors may use the argument to struggle an madness protection. “When you’re succesful sufficient to have an argument along with your mother and father at a Christmas occasion … you aren’t insane,” Rahmani stated.
Madness protection has challenges
Protection legal professional Dmitry Gorin, a former L.A. County prosecutor, stated Jackson’s first process is assessing his shopper’s psychological well being. That evaluation may in the end result in a not responsible by madness plea, however may additionally present proof to maneuver Reiner from the county jail to a personal psychiatric facility.
“A very powerful factor in legal instances is to have the shoppers get rapid therapy, and have the ability to cooperate in his protection, which is not going to occur whereas he’s in jail,” he stated.
Gorin stated that the madness protection is especially robust in California, and that in uncommon instances it should be proved {that a} defendant didn’t know proper from fallacious.
“The burden of proof is on the protection in an madness case, and the jury might even see the protection as an excuse for committing a critical crime,” he stated. “The jury units a really excessive bar on the defendant as a result of it understands that it’ll launch him from obligation.”
Sources instructed The Instances that after the killing, Nick Reiner went to a lodge in Santa Monica. He was arrested that Sunday night time close to USC. His general actions that day stay unclear.
Neither Jackson nor prosecutors would touch upon the route of the case.
‘Advanced’ points
Jackson has referred to as the killings “a devastating tragedy. However he cautioned the general public to not rush to judgment or bounce to conclusions, saying there are “very advanced and critical points” that should be “completely, however very rigorously, handled and examined and checked out and analyzed.”
Nick Reiner’s dependancy has been public for years.
He has stated in interviews that he turned hooked on heroin as an adolescent, and had cycled out and in of rehabilitation facilities and skilled bouts of homelessness. Reiner stated he was not utilizing by 2015, when he co-wrote “Being Charlie,” a movie a few drug-addicted younger man whose father is a chilly former film star working for governor of California. Rob Reiner directed the movie.
Nick Reiner has no legal historical past and on the time of the killing was residing within the again home of the Reiners’ property.
