By MARYCLAIRE DALE
PHILADELPHIA (AP) — A federal choose warned Justice Division attorneys on Friday that they had been making “harmful” and “horrifying” statements after they stated the Trump Administration can resolve what a part of American historical past to show at Nationwide Park Service websites.
The sharp change erupted throughout a listening to in Philadelphia over the abrupt elimination of an exhibit on the historical past of slavery on the web site of the previous President’s Home on Independence Mall.
The town, which labored in tandem with the park service on the exhibit 20 years in the past, was shocked to search out employees this month utilizing crowbars to take away out of doors plaques, panels and different supplies that informed the tales of the 9 individuals who had been enslaved there. A number of the historical past had solely been unearthed up to now quarter-century.
“You’ll be able to’t erase historical past when you’ve realized it. It doesn’t work that manner,” stated Senior U.S. District Decide Cynthia Rufe, an appointee of President George W. Bush.
An individual strikes to {photograph} the situation of the now eliminated explanatory panels that had been a part of an exhibit on slavery at President’s Home Website in Philadelphia, Friday, Jan. 30, 2026. (AP Photograph/Matt Rourke)
1 of 4
An individual strikes to {photograph} the situation of the now eliminated explanatory panels that had been a part of an exhibit on slavery at President’s Home Website in Philadelphia, Friday, Jan. 30, 2026. (AP Photograph/Matt Rourke)
The elimination adopted President Donald Trump’s govt order “restoring reality and sanity to American historical past” on the nation’s museums, parks and landmarks. In Philadelphia, the supplies had been put in a pickup truck after which into storage, main Rufe to voice issues about whether or not they had been broken.
“Though many individuals really feel strongly about this (exhibit) a technique, different individuals could disagree or really feel strongly one other manner,” stated Assistant U.S. Lawyer Gregory in den Berken.
“Finally,” he stated, “the federal government will get to decide on the message it desires to convey.”
Rufe swiftly minimize him off.
“That may be a harmful assertion you make. It’s horrifying to take heed to,” she stated. “It adjustments on the whims of somebody in cost? I’m sorry, that isn’t what we elected anyone for.”
Rufe heard hours of testimony Friday from former metropolis officers who had helped plan the exhibit, and stated the town had kicked in $1.5 million towards the undertaking. She plans to go to each the storage space and the location earlier than ruling on the town’s request to have the exhibit restored. However she requested the Justice Division attorneys to make sure that nothing else is disturbed.
In den Berken stated the Park Service routinely adjustments its reveals and excursions, and argued that the federal government can’t be compelled to inform a sure story. However attorneys for the town and different advocates stated the park service doesn’t have “carte blanche” to interpret the nation’s historical past because it sees match.
The exhibit contains biographical particulars concerning the 9 individuals enslaved by George and Martha Washington on the presidential mansion. Now, solely their names — Austin, Paris, Hercules, Christopher Sheels, Richmond, Giles, Oney Decide, Moll and Joe — stay engraved right into a cement wall.
Michael Coard, an legal professional representing one of many advocacy teams supporting the exhibit, stated the president was ignoring the facility held by Congress, the judiciary and the American individuals.
“It’s one factor to whisper that kind of dictatorial energy. However to ship attorneys right into a public courtroom to make that argument is totally horrifying,” he stated. “I’m actually nervous concerning the state of America.”
Rufe stated she deliberate to rule shortly, noting the surge of holiday makers anticipated to go to the nation’s birthplace this yr to mark its 250th anniversary of being based.
Residents who’ve visited the location have shed tears, left flowers and left a hand-crafted signal that stated “Slavery was actual.”
