Pope Leo XIV says ‘inhuman remedy of immigrants’ within the U.S. is not ‘pro-life’ : NPR

VATICAN CITY — Pope Leo XIV weighed in on U.S. politics, saying that Catholic politicians have to be judged on the complete vary of their coverage positions and suggesting that the nation’s remedy of immigrants is “inhuman.”

“Somebody who says I am towards abortion however is in favor of the loss of life penalty will not be actually pro-life,” Pope Leo mentioned. “And somebody who says I am towards abortion however I am in settlement with the inhuman remedy of immigrants in the US, I do not know if that is pro-life.”

The remarks signify the primary American pope’s first foray as pontiff into his native nation’s pitched debates over abortion, immigration and the Catholic Church’s position in civil society.

White Home Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt was requested in regards to the Pope’s feedback on Wednesday.

“I might reject there’s inhumane remedy of unlawful immigrants in the US below this administration,” Leavitt instructed reporters on the White Home. “There was, nevertheless, vital, inhumane remedy of unlawful immigrants within the earlier administration as they had been being trafficked and raped and crushed, in lots of instances killed over our United States southern border.”

Earlier than he was elected Pope on Could 8, Leo — then referred to as Cardinal Robert Prevost — shared articles on social media that had been vital of the Trump administration’s rhetoric and insurance policies on immigration.

A papal press gaggle

The Pope’s temporary remarks got here in response to questions from reporters who gathered exterior of his summer time residence in Castel Gandolfo on Tuesday night.

One reporter requested the Chicago-born pontiff in regards to the controversy over plans to honor Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin with a lifetime achievement award by a Catholic establishment — regardless of the Illinois lawmaker’s help for abortion rights.

Leo mentioned he wasn’t “very aware of the case,” however he mentioned the award was a recognition of Durbin’s “total work” throughout greater than 40 years of service in Congress.

“I perceive the problem and the tensions. However I believe as I actually have spoken prior to now, it is vital to contemplate many points associated to the instructing of the Church,” mentioned Leo.

The pope urged folks concerned within the U.S. — and his native state of Illinois — to “have respect for each other” whereas reminding devoted that the instructing of the Catholic Church on these points is “very clear.”

On Sept. 22, Chicago Cardinal Blase Cupich introduced he could be presenting Durbin with the award on the upcoming Maintain Hope Alive gala in acknowledgment of Durbin’s help for migrants.

Critics, together with Bishop Thomas Paprocki of Springfield, Illinois, the place Durbin lives, condemned the award due to the senator’s previous help for abortion rights. Paprocki has denied Communion for Durbin since 2004.

Durbin, whose fifth time period within the Senate ends in January of 2027, has mentioned that he is not going to search re-election.

Shortly after the pope’s remarks, Cupich issued an announcement asserting Durbin has declined to obtain the award.

“Whereas I’m saddened by this information, I respect his determination,” wrote the cardinal, who confused that the award was in recognition of “his unwavering help of immigrants, which is so wanted in our day.”

Cupich additionally lamented the rising partisan divide inside the U.S., which he mentioned leaves Catholics “politically homeless.” Whereas church instructing bars honoring politicians who help insurance policies opposite to Catholic doctrine, he mentioned no chief constantly embodies Catholic social instructing.

“Whole condemnation will not be the way in which ahead, for it shuts down dialogue,” the cardinal mentioned.

This story was produced via a collaboration between NPR and Faith Information Service.